EME station planning: what 2 m, 70 cm, 23 cm and 10 GHz really require (JT65/Q65, polarization, libration, skeds)
- Replies 2
- Views 30
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
This thread is meant as a working checklist for anyone deciding which band to start EME on and what to build. Corrections and extra numbers are welcome. The figures below are rough planning values, so run your own link budget with a tool like EMECalc before spending money on aluminum or a dish.
Start with the physics. Round-trip path loss to the Moon is roughly 250 dB on 144 MHz, around 260 dB on 432 MHz, about 270 dB on 1296 MHz and close to 290 dB at 10 GHz. The Moon is a poor reflector, so what comes back is tiny. The echo delay is about 2.5 seconds, which is how you recognize your own echoes. Moon distance changes between perigee and apogee, which swings path loss by around 2 dB. Perigee weeks are the best time to try marginal setups or microwave skeds.
The digital modes are what make small stations possible. JT65 is the long-time standard, with 60-second periods and a 64-tone design that decodes well below the audible noise floor. Q65 in WSJT-X is the newer option and is usually better when signals are smeared by libration or when you can average several periods. Submodes set the tone spacing, so wider submodes cope with more Doppler spread. Common practice is a narrow submode on 2 m and progressively wider ones on 70 cm, 23 cm and the microwave bands. Check what your sked partner or the activity group uses before you pick one, because mismatched submodes mean no decode.
Station requirements by band, as a rough guide:
2 m: Several long-boom Yagis in a stacked array, typically four or more, giving gain in the low-to-mid 20s dBi. Add several hundred watts to a kilowatt where legal, and a very low noise preamp at the antenna. Sky noise is high on 144 MHz, so feedline loss before the preamp and relay loss matter a lot. Faraday rotation is strong here, so polarization control is a real design question.
70 cm: More gain is needed for the same signal, but the arrays are physically smaller. Multiple Yagis or a modest dish with a good feed are the usual routes. Faraday rotation is slower and less severe than on 2 m, but it is not gone.
23 cm: This is where dishes take over. A 3 m dish is roughly 29 to 30 dBi at 1296 MHz, and 4 m is around 32 dBi, depending on efficiency. Power in the 100 to several hundred watt range at the feed, plus a low-loss receive path with the preamp very close to the feed, is the usual formula. Faraday rotation is minor here, so many stations use circular polarization.
10 GHz and up: Dishes in the 1.8 to 3 m class are typical, with low-noise converters and power amplifiers mounted at the feed. Frequency stability becomes a serious issue, and a GPS-disciplined reference is common. Tracking accuracy matters most here, since beamwidth is only about a degree. Libration spread also grows, which is part of why wider Q65 submodes exist.
Questions for the thread: what is the smallest setup you would recommend per band for working big stations only, and what is the point where adding more antennas stops being the best use of money compared with improving the receive system?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11520-eme-station-planning-what-2-m-70-cm-23-cm-and-10-ghz-really-require-jt65q65-polarization-libration-skeds/Share on other sites