LoTW, eQSL, Club Log OQRS, bureau or direct: how are you confirming contacts, and what actually counts for DXCC?
- Replies 2
- Views 22
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
There are more ways to confirm a QSO than ever, and they are not interchangeable. Here is how I understand the main options. Correct me if I have any of it wrong, and tell me what you do with each.
Logbook of The World (LoTW) is the ARRL system and the one most people lean on for DXCC. You install TQSL, request a callsign certificate, and sign your log uploads with it. The certificate request involves a verification step, and for a new callsign or a first request it can take a while, so do not wait until the night you want to upload. A confirmation only happens when both stations upload and the QSOs match on callsign, band, mode and time within the allowed window. So a missing confirmation often just means the other operator has not uploaded. Mismatched entities and station locations (wrong grid, CQ zone or DXCC entity in the TQSL station location) cause plenty of trouble, and a wrong one can mean a QSO never matches or gets credited to the wrong place.
eQSL and the QRZ logbook are convenient and widely used, but they are a different category. As I understand it, eQSL confirmations, including Authenticity Guaranteed ones, are not accepted for DXCC credit. They are still nice for award programs that do accept them, for chasing a confirmation on a casual contact, and for seeing a pretty card. QRZ logbook matching works similarly. It is a confirmation of sorts between two logs, not DXCC currency. Check the current rules of whatever award you are chasing, because those can change.
Paper is still alive. A paper card can be submitted for DXCC through the ARRL's card checking process, so a card from a rare entity can matter even if the operator never touches LoTW. Bureau cards go through your national QSL bureau, which is cheap and very slow, and the delay is measured in months or longer, not days. Direct cards go by post to the station's QSL manager or address. The usual etiquette is to send your card, a self-addressed envelope (SASE) and return postage. For DX stations, that traditionally meant green stamps (US dollars) or whatever the station asks for. Return postage costs change, and IRCs are not something I would count on. Look up the station's QSL instructions on QRZ.com or its own page before sending anything.
Club Log's OQRS (Online QSL Request System) sits in the middle. If the DX station uploads to Club Log and enables OQRS, you request a card online and choose bureau or direct, and the operator or manager mails it. Some stations ask for a fee or a donation for direct. Some will upload to LoTW but only fulfill paper through OQRS. Always read the station's note first.
Then there is the card itself. A good card shows your callsign big and readable, date and time in UTC, band, mode, RST, the other station's callsign, grid, CQ/ITU zone, and a clear QSL line such as PSE/TNX. The standard bureau size (roughly 3.5 by 5.5 inches) sorts and travels better than odd shapes. A photo or artwork is nice, but if the log details are hard to find on the back, the card is less useful, especially for card checking.
A few questions for the group. Do you print cards at all anymore, or is everything LoTW plus the occasional direct request? How long do you wait before deciding a bureau card is lost? And for people working toward DXCC, are you mostly digital, or do you keep a paper route open for entities where nobody uploads?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11526-lotw-eqsl-club-log-oqrs-bureau-or-direct-how-are-you-confirming-contacts-and-what-actually-counts-for-dxcc/Share on other sites