VHF/UHF antenna choices: J-pole vs slim jim vs 5/8 wave vs collinear, and where the feedline and connectors fit
- Replies 2
- Views 32
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
This thread is for comparing common VHF/UHF antenna types, and it covers the parts that often matter more than the antenna: coax, connectors, mounting and measurement. Take a typical dual-band 2 m / 70 cm setup used for local FM, a repeater or two, and the occasional satellite pass. Which antennas make sense, and what are the trade-offs?
Quarter-wave whip. This is the simplest vertical. At 146 MHz it is roughly 19 inches, and at 446 MHz about 6.5 inches. It has about unity gain relative to a dipole and a low radiation angle, and it is forgiving. It needs a decent ground plane, which on a vehicle means the roof or body. It is hard to beat for a first mobile antenna, but it gives up the extra gain that a longer antenna can offer.
5/8 wave. A 5/8 wave whip is about 51 inches on 2 m. It concentrates more energy toward the horizon, and the commonly quoted figure is around 3 dBd. In practice that depends on the ground plane and on the matching coil at the base. A 5/8 wave over a poor or tiny ground plane can underperform a quarter wave, and the pattern can tilt upward. Dual-band mobile antennas often use a 5/8 wave on 2 m and a pair of stacked 5/8 sections on 70 cm. Those pieces are pre-tuned, so the quoted gain assumes the ground plane the manufacturer expected.
J-pole and slim jim. Both are end-fed half-wave verticals matched by a quarter-wave stub, so they need no radial set. A slim jim is a folded variant, typically built from twin-lead or tubing, with a somewhat lower takeoff angle and slightly more gain than a basic J-pole. They are cheap, have a good pattern and are easy to build. The weak point is that the feedline can become part of the antenna. If the coax radiates, the pattern distorts and the SWR changes as you move the cable. A choke at the feedpoint, such as ferrites or a few turns of coax, helps. Keep the antenna away from metal masts or place it above them.
Collinears. A collinear stacks phased half-wave elements to squeeze the vertical pattern toward the horizon. Gain is around 6 dBd for a big commercial one, but the vertical beamwidth is narrow. This works well for a repeater or a base station on flat terrain. It can work against you if you are on a hill and the other station is below the main lobe, and a mechanically bent or tilted mast makes it worse.
Yagis. A three-element 2 m yagi might offer roughly 5 to 7 dBd, with front-to-back ratio and beamwidth varying with design. The directivity cuts noise and interference from behind and the sides, and it needs a rotator or a manual aim. Polarization has to match: vertical for FM, horizontal for typical weak-signal SSB/CW work on 144 MHz.
Polarization. Between a vertical antenna and a horizontal one, theoretical cross-polarization loss is large, often quoted around 20 dB, though real-world reflections reduce this. Handhelds are held at arbitrary angles, so mismatch is a common reason for fluctuating signals. Satellite work usually favors circular polarization, such as crossed yagis or a turnstile. A handheld Arrow-style yagi is the common portable approach for FM LEO satellites, with the operator manually correcting for Doppler and tracking.
Repeater antennas. These are usually omnidirectional collinears on hardline. With a single antenna, a duplexer separates transmit and receive. With two antennas, vertical separation provides isolation. Low-loss line is crucial because every dB lost on receive and transmit changes the coverage footprint, and desense from the repeater's own transmitter is a constant concern.
Mag mounts and NMO. A magnetic mount couples capacitively to the metal beneath it, so a roof-center position over bare, clean metal gives the best pattern. It is convenient, but the coax routing through a door gasket or window can be damaged. NMO is a threaded mount that goes through a 3/4 inch hole and gives a solid mechanical and electrical connection. Choose a mount with good ground contact, because poor grounding can cause SWR problems and noise. Trunk-lip and similar mounts work but often have grounding compromises.
Coax and loss. Coax loss rises sharply with frequency. RG-58 is fine for a short jumper but gets lossy fast on UHF. An LMR-400-class cable loses roughly 1.4 dB per 100 ft at 150 MHz and about 2.5 dB per 100 ft at 450 MHz; check the datasheet for the exact cable you buy. For a long mast run on 70 cm, that adds up quickly.
Connectors. The PL-259 (UHF connector) is common, cheap and fine on HF and 2 m. It is not constant impedance and is not weatherproof, and it is a poorer choice as you approach UHF. N-type is constant impedance, weather-sealed with a gasket, and generally better for outdoor UHF runs. Use the proper reducer with thin coax and make solid solder joints on the shield. Every adapter adds loss and a potential water entry point, so minimize them.
SWR. SWR measured at the radio end is not a quality score for the antenna. A dummy load reads 1:1, and a lossy cable can make a bad antenna look better than it is, because the reflected power is attenuated twice by the cable. Low SWR means a good match. It does not mean good radiation. Measure at the antenna end when practical, and judge the whole system by actual signal reports or field strength comparisons.
Where do you draw the line between a build-it-yourself J-pole or slim jim and a commercial collinear? And for mixed terrestrial and satellite use, would you split the job between two antennas or look for a compromise?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11560-vhfuhf-antenna-choices-j-pole-vs-slim-jim-vs-58-wave-vs-collinear-and-where-the-feedline-and-connectors-fit/Share on other sites