Choosing a handheld: FT-65R vs Baofeng, D-STAR options (ID-52A, TH-D75), where the IC-705 fits, and what actually matters for emergency use
- Replies 2
- Views 26
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Terry 1 post
-
Mod_Tom 1 post
This is a general discussion thread for anyone picking a first HT or trying to decide whether to move up from a cheap one. The radios named here sit in very different places, so it helps to sort them by what they do before comparing prices or specs.
Analog FM dual-banders. The Baofeng UV-5R family and the Yaesu FT-65R are 2 m / 70 cm FM handhelds. They cover the most common repeater and simplex activity and have the lowest cost of entry. The FT-65R is generally seen as the more polished design, with a better receiver and a more conventional build. Baofeng's strength is price and the huge supply of accessories. The usual complaints about budget Baofengs are weaker receiver selectivity in RF-heavy areas (strong pagers or commercial transmitters can cause overload) and spurious emissions that can be worse than on name-brand radios. Neither is a DMR or D-STAR radio.
D-STAR handhelds. The Icom ID-52A and Kenwood TH-D75 are digital-voice HTs that also work as normal analog FM radios. D-STAR is only worth buying if there are D-STAR repeaters or reflectors you will actually use. The TH-D75 adds 220 MHz in North American versions, plus built-in APRS and GPS features. The ID-52A is a dual-band D-STAR radio with GPS and Bluetooth. Check the current spec sheets for exact features. Both cost several times what an FM-only radio does, so decide whether you will use the extras.
The IC-705 is a different category. It is a portable HF/50/144/430 MHz transceiver with D-STAR, not a pocket HT. It is a good fit for portable HF or SOTA/POTA-style operating. It is a poor substitute for something that rides on your belt, and it needs a proper antenna and a field kit to be useful. Consider it a second radio, not an HT replacement.
DMR. None of the radios above do DMR. DMR handhelds come from other makers and have a steeper setup curve. You need a DMR radio ID, the right color code and timeslot for each repeater, talkgroup contacts, and usually the manufacturer's programming software. Like D-STAR, it is only useful if your area has active DMR repeaters.
Programming. CHIRP is the usual tool for analog memories on many Baofeng and Yaesu models, and it lets you import repeater lists and keep a backup. Check CHIRP's supported-radio list for your exact model before you buy, because support varies and some newer or digital-focused radios are not covered or are only partly covered. Always download the radio's existing image before writing changes to it. For repeater entries, the common US conventions are:
Offsets and band plans are different in other countries, so verify locally.
Batteries and antennas. A spare battery matters more than a few extra watts. Look for a battery that is easy to charge on the road (a USB-C or drop-in charger helps) and consider an AA-cell case or a DC cable if one is offered for your model. Keep Li-ion packs charged but not stored full for months. On antennas, the stock rubber duck is a compromise. A longer whip such as a Nagoya-style replacement often improves performance, but check the connector first, because Baofengs typically use an SMA-female radio jack and some other radios use different gender or connector types. Height is usually the biggest improvement. Keep the antenna out of your body's shadow, or use a roll-up J-pole with an adapter when you can hang it up.
Emergency use. A radio is not a plan. Program your local repeaters, the national simplex calling frequencies (146.520 and 446.000 in the US), and NOAA weather channels before you need them. Keep a paper copy of the channel list. Know your local ARES/RACES or club net information. Only transmit where your license permits. Do not use an HT to key up on public safety or other frequencies you are not authorized for, even if the radio will physically do it.
Questions to get started: what is your budget, what repeaters are near you (analog, D-STAR, or DMR), and do you want a simple radio you can leave in a go-bag or a feature-rich one you will use every day?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11562-choosing-a-handheld-ft-65r-vs-baofeng-d-star-options-id-52a-th-d75-where-the-ic-705-fits-and-what-actually-matters-for-emergency-use/Share on other sites