Dual-band mobile setups: FTM-500D vs ID-5100A vs TM-D710G, plus wiring, noise and etiquette
- Replies 2
- Views 24
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Terry 1 post
-
Admin_Lee 1 post
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
This thread is for sorting out the practical side of a 2 meter / 70 centimeter mobile install, whichever rig you're running. The three radios that come up most for this kind of build are the Yaesu FTM-500D, the Icom ID-5100A and the Kenwood TM-D710G. They overlap a lot, but they lean in different directions.
The FTM-500D and ID-5100A are digital-mode radios. The Yaesu is built around C4FM and the Icom around D-STAR, so the choice often comes down to which network your local repeaters and friends use. The TM-D710G is more of an analog FM and APRS platform, with a built-in TNC and GPS support. It's a common choice for people who care about position reporting and messaging. Before buying, check the current manual for your exact model and firmware. Feature lists like cross-band repeat, APRS behavior and display options differ by radio and sometimes by region.
Cross-band repeat is a good example. Some dual-band mobiles can receive on one band and retransmit on the other, which is handy for extending a handheld's reach from a vehicle with a better antenna. Not every dual-band rig offers it. Even where it exists, you are still responsible for identification, licensing privileges and control operator requirements under your local rules. A few practical points:
On power wiring, the safest approach is the one the manufacturer intends. Run the supplied power cable directly to the battery, not to a cigarette lighter socket or an accessory fuse tap that wasn't sized for the load. Keep the fuses in the positive lead close to the battery. If you extend the cable, use wire at least as heavy as the original and keep the run short. Never replace a fuse with a larger one just to stop it blowing. A fuse that keeps blowing is telling you something, such as a bad crimp, a short, or a radio problem. Use a grommet where the cable passes through the firewall so it can't chafe on sheet metal.
Mounting matters too. The control head or the main body should be secure enough not to become a projectile in a hard stop, and it should sit where you can reach it without taking your eyes off the road. Don't mount anything in an airbag deployment zone. Run coax so it isn't pinched by doors, and avoid tight bends.
For noise, start with the antenna and the cable routes. Alternator whine usually shows up as a pitch that follows engine RPM. It's often reduced by good power connections at the battery, keeping coax away from power cables, and sometimes adding a ferrite choke or a power-line filter. Aftermarket LED lighting, USB chargers and DC-DC converters can radiate hash on VHF or UHF. Turn accessories off one at a time and see what changes on a quiet frequency.
Finally, etiquette. Listen before you transmit, keep your transmissions short, don't turn a repeater into a private channel, and let others finish. Hands-free or voice-controlled operation is better than fiddling with menus while driving. Local distracted-driving laws may apply to radio use.
Questions for the thread: what antenna are you using, where is it mounted, and what noise problems have you tracked down? Which radio did you choose, and what ended up mattering more than the spec sheet?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11574-dual-band-mobile-setups-ftm-500d-vs-id-5100a-vs-tm-d710g-plus-wiring-noise-and-etiquette/Share on other sites