Building a light POTA/SOTA go-kit: EFHW vs. linked dipole, pole, LiFePO4 and logging – what's your split?
- Replies 2
- Views 32
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
-
Mod_Nancy 1 post
I want to compare approaches to a portable kit that works for both park activations and summit trips. The weight and complexity budget is very different for a drive-up POTA spot and a SOTA climb, but plenty of gear overlaps. Here is how I'd break it down, and I'd like to hear where you'd draw the lines.
Antenna: EFHW or linked dipole? An end-fed half wave (EFHW) with a 49:1 or 64:1 transformer is popular because it is quick to deploy. A 40 m version is roughly 20 m (about 66 ft) of wire, and it also works on the harmonics (20, 15 and 10 m) with no tuning at the feed point. The tradeoffs are that the transformer and coax shield behave as part of the antenna. A small counterpoise helps, and a common-mode choke at the feedpoint is cheap insurance against RF in the shack and a shifting SWR when you move the coax. A linked dipole is a center-fed antenna with sections you connect or disconnect, which gives a balanced pattern and usually a very predictable match on each band. The price is manual changes: walking the wire, opening links and getting everything back together in the cold with gloves on.
Support: telescopic pole. A 6 m or 10 m (about 20 or 33 ft) fiberglass pole is the usual choice. For an EFHW as an inverted L or sloper, the pole's weak spots matter more than the height rating. Collapsed sections can slip, so a hose clamp or tape wrap on the joints helps. Guy it with light cord at the upper third in anything but a calm breeze. Whatever the setup, stay well clear of power lines and any tree that could drop a limb on you.
Power: LiFePO4 and solar. LiFePO4 is a good match for 12 V radios. The nominal voltage is about 12.8 V, and the voltage curve stays flat until the battery is nearly empty. Two things to plan for: a battery management system (BMS) can cut off abruptly when it hits low-voltage protection, so you'll want a way to monitor state of charge, such as an inline meter. And LiFePO4 cells should not be charged below freezing unless the battery specifically has low-temperature charge protection. That matters if you plan to run a solar panel in winter. If you're using a panel, use a charge controller with a LiFePO4 profile, not just a raw panel into the battery. For flying, lithium batteries are limited by watt-hours and airline policy, so check the current rules for your carrier before you pack.
Logging. Logging on a phone or tablet is convenient, but plan for dead batteries, no signal and glare. Many operators keep a paper log as a backup, with pencil because pens fail in the cold. Whatever you use, write down callsign, time in UTC, band, mode and reference number as you go, and clean up after the activation. A quick way to check you've met the requirements for the program (POTA and SOTA each have their own minimum contact counts and rules, so check the current ones) is to count contacts before you pack up, not after.
Weather and safety. Pack for the conditions, tell someone your plan and return time, and treat thunderstorms as a stop signal. On a summit or open park field, you're the tall object. A good rule is to take the antenna down and move before the storm gets close, not once it's overhead.
Questions for the thread: Where do you put the weight on a SOTA trip, and what do you leave at home for a drive-up POTA setup? Do you run one antenna for everything or have separate kits? What's the one item you'd add to a basic kit?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11613-building-a-light-potasota-go-kit-efhw-vs-linked-dipole-pole-lifepo4-and-logging-whats-your-split/Share on other sites