Run vs. S&P, band changes and SO2R: how do you decide when to leave a good run frequency?
- Replies 2
- Views 29
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Terry 1 post
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
This is a discussion starter for anyone who thinks about contest strategy as a numbers problem, not just a feeling. The question is when you should leave a productive run frequency to hunt multipliers, change bands or let the second radio work.
A simple way to frame it is that every minute spent on a run frequency is worth your current rate, and every minute spent searching and pouncing has to beat that. Look at the rate window in N1MM Logger+ (or whatever logger you use) and compare the last 10 minutes with the last hour. If the short-term rate has fallen well below the hourly rate and CQs are going unanswered, the frequency is probably dying or the band is changing. A single slow minute means nothing, but five or six minutes of thin returns is a signal.
The marginal-value math is worth doing before the contest, because it tells you how hard to chase multipliers. In a contest scored as QSO points times multipliers, one more QSO adds roughly your current multiplier count in points, and one more multiplier adds roughly your current QSO points. As a hypothetical example, suppose you have 2,000 QSO points and 200 multipliers. A new QSO is worth about 200 points, and a new multiplier is worth about 2,000, or about ten QSOs. Early in the contest, when the multiplier count is low, QSOs are cheap and multipliers are not yet scarce. Later, the rare multipliers are the ones that matter. Whether multipliers count once per contest or once per band changes this a lot, so read the exchange and scoring rules for each event instead of assuming.
On band changes, the usual advice is to be on the band that is actually open, not the band you prefer. Use propagation knowledge (grayline, expected openings by time of day) alongside what the skimmer and spots show you. A band that looks quiet on your own receiver may be full of signals toward a region your antenna isn't pointing at. Changing bands also has a cost in lost rate, so a useful habit is to change when the run rate on the current band has clearly fallen and the new band has shown signs of life, not on a fixed schedule.
SO2R changes the problem. The standard pattern is to call CQ on radio 1 and use the gaps to search on radio 2 for multipliers or new stations. That only works if the setup supports it. You need good receive isolation between the radios, band-pass or stub filtering where bands are close, enough antenna separation or the right antenna choices, and clean audio switching so you can hear both radios without confusion. If radio 2 is desensing radio 1, or transmit harmonics are showing up on the other band, the setup is costing you more than it gains. Many operators start with a modest SO2R arrangement, such as a footswitch, a headphone switch and a keyer interface, and grow it from there.
Then there is assistance. Skimmer and packet spotting can make S&P much more efficient because you are not tuning blindly, but whether you can use them depends on your entry category. Unassisted categories generally prohibit spots, while assisted categories allow them. Many contests also have rules about self-spotting and about using skimmer output in non-assisted entries. Check the specific contest's rules before you set up the software.
Last, fatigue. Rate falls and mistakes rise as you tire, and a long contest rewards a plan. That includes scheduled breaks timed to the weakest band conditions, food and water you don't have to think about, and a decision about how much sleep you need to keep your late-contest rate from collapsing. An operator who is awake but making copy errors may be losing more points to busted calls and lost QSOs than a short nap would cost.
Questions to get things started: What rate drop tells you it's time to leave a run frequency? How do you set band-change timing when two bands look similar? And what is the first SO2R improvement you would recommend to someone who has only worked single-radio so far?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11651-run-vs-sp-band-changes-and-so2r-how-do-you-decide-when-to-leave-a-good-run-frequency/Share on other sites