Scratch-building a multiband wire antenna: wire, insulators, feedline, chokes and how far to trust the model
- Replies 2
- Views 15
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
This thread is for the practical decisions in a from-scratch wire antenna build, the ones that decide whether it works for years or needs fixing every spring. Add your own numbers and corrections. Here are the starting points, followed by a few questions.
Wire. For a fixed dipole, 14 AWG hard-drawn copper or copper-clad steel is a common choice. Copper-clad steel barely stretches, so the resonant frequency stays put as the span ages. For spans over about 80 feet, or in ice and wind, 12 AWG is worth the extra weight. Stranded insulated wire is easier to handle and coil, but the insulation lowers the velocity factor, so expect the antenna to resonate a few percent low. Bare wire is longer than insulated wire for the same frequency. Start with the cut length calculated and leave extra to fold back at each end. Trimming is easier than splicing.
Starting lengths. The usual half-wave formula, 468 divided by the frequency in MHz, gives total length in feet. At 7.1 MHz that is about 66 feet, or 33 feet per leg. At 14.2 MHz it is about 33 feet, or 16.5 feet per leg. Treat these only as a starting point. Height above ground, nearby objects, wire diameter and end-effect all shift resonance. Cut long, measure, and trim the same amount from each end.
Insulators and supports. End insulators carry mechanical load, so the wire must not be the weakest part of the joint. Pass the wire through the hole twice and twist it back on itself. Use polyester (Dacron) or another UV-resistant rope rather than nylon, which stretches and weakens in sunlight. At the center, take the strain off the solder joints with a proper center insulator or a plate with a strain-relief hole, and let the coax weight hang from the support, not the wire. Seal the coax end, because water wicks into braid and ruins the feedline from the inside.
Fiberglass poles. Telescoping fiberglass masts in the 30 to 40 foot class are popular for inverted-vees and verticals because they are non-conductive and light. Clean and tape the sections, or use hose clamps, so the pole does not collapse in wind. Do not let a wire vertical run right alongside a metal mast, because that changes the feedpoint impedance. A pole holds up much better if it is guyed or lashed at a couple of points.
Feedline and common-mode current. A coax-fed dipole wants a 1:1 current balun or a common-mode choke. Typically that is several turns of coax, roughly 8 to 12, wound on a large ferrite toroid such as an FT240 in a 31 or 43 mix. Mix choice depends on the band, so verify with a VNA rather than trusting a rule of thumb. For a ladder-line doublet, 450 ohm window line has low loss even at high SWR. Keep it away from metal, avoid sharp bends, and put the balun or choke where the line meets the tuner and coax. Some doublet lengths put a very high impedance at the feedpoint on certain bands, so check the length in a model before you cut.
Verticals and radials. A quarter-wave vertical is about 234 divided by the frequency in MHz, in feet. Elevated radials resonate and work well in small numbers. With two to four sloping radials, the feedpoint impedance moves toward 50 ohms. Ground-mounted radials need many more wires, since a handful does not make a good ground screen.
Traps vs. fan dipoles. A trap is a parallel LC circuit resonant at the upper band. It isolates the outer wire on that band and loads the antenna on the lower one. The capacitor needs a voltage rating and temperature stability suited to your power level, and each trap must be tuned and checked, for example with a grid-dip meter or a VNA with a coupling loop. Traps save space but add losses and mechanical complexity. A fan dipole costs only extra wire and spreaders. It has interaction between elements and takes more care to tune.
Measuring. Measure at the feedpoint if you can, with the choke in place. Coax loss can make the SWR at the radio end look better than the antenna actually is. Minimum SWR does not always coincide with zero reactance, so look at R and X, not just SWR. Calibrate a NanoVNA or antenna analyzer at the end of the cable you are measuring through.
Modeling. Both EZNEC and MMANA let you test a design before cutting wire. Set the real ground type, the wire conductivity, and enough segments per wire. Check the average gain test in NEC-based programs. Junctions of very different wire diameters can give bad results. Models predict trends well and absolute resonance only roughly, so build with trimming margin.
Questions for discussion: What is the best way to verify a choke's common-mode impedance on the bench? Where does a trap dipole beat a fan dipole in a real installation? And how many radials do you consider enough for an elevated vertical?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11674-scratch-building-a-multiband-wire-antenna-wire-insulators-feedline-chokes-and-how-far-to-trust-the-model/Share on other sites