Getting started with EME: what each band demands, JT65 vs Q65, polarization, libration and planning skeds
- Replies 2
- Views 21
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Mod_Tom 1 post
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
This thread is meant as a working overview for people deciding which band to try for moonbounce, and a place to correct the rough numbers below. Treat the figures as ballpark and check them against your own station calculations.
The basic problem is path loss. Round-trip loss to the Moon and back is on the order of 252 dB on 144 MHz, about 261 dB on 432 MHz, about 271 dB on 1296 MHz and around 290 dB on 10 GHz. The Moon's distance changes over each orbit, so path loss swings by a little over 2 dB between perigee and apogee. That is one reason the same station can be marginal one week and comfortable the next. The echo delay is about 2.5 seconds, which is why the weak-signal digital modes use alternating one-minute periods rather than anything interactive.
On 2 m, the usual serious entry point is a phased array of several long Yagis, a mast-mounted low-noise preamp, and hundreds of watts to a kilowatt at the antenna. On 70 cm, people use either more Yagis or a dish, because wavelength shrinks and individual gain per element goes up, but pointing and feedline loss get less forgiving. On 23 cm, dishes dominate, and a few metres of aperture is a common starting point for working larger stations. On 10 GHz, a well-built dish with a good LNA and tens of watts can work, but pointing accuracy, feed alignment and frequency stability become the main challenges.
For modes, JT65 has long been the standard for EME QSOs, and Q65 is the newer option in WSJT-X, generally with somewhat better weak-signal performance and submodes chosen according to Doppler spread. Spread grows with frequency, so the submode that suits 2 m is not the one that suits 23 cm or 10 GHz. Check the current WSJT-X documentation and the activity on your band before choosing. The Echo mode in WSJT-X is worth using before any sked, because hearing your own echoes is the most direct end-to-end test of antenna, pointing, receiver, transmit power and Doppler tracking.
Two propagation effects deserve their own discussion. Faraday rotation twists the polarization of lower-band signals, so a fixed linear antenna can see deep fades as the received polarization rotates. It matters most on 2 m, less on 70 cm, and is generally negligible by 23 cm. Libration fading comes from the Moon's apparent rocking, which spreads the reflected signal in frequency and produces rapid flutter. It gets worse as frequency rises, from a small fraction of a hertz on VHF to tens or hundreds of hertz in the microwave range.
For people planning a first EME setup, which band gives the best return for the effort and cost? And what do you consider the minimum useful polarization and tracking capability on each band?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11677-getting-started-with-eme-what-each-band-demands-jt65-vs-q65-polarization-libration-and-planning-skeds/Share on other sites