Small lot or HOA: EFHW, OCFD, doublet, vertical or loop? What actually decides the result
- Replies 2
- Views 15
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
-
Mod_Nancy 1 post
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
This comes up constantly: a lot of roughly 50 x 80 ft, a house in the middle, no tower, and either a covenant or a spouse who objects to anything that looks like an antenna. The question is usually "which antenna should I buy or build?" The better question is what you can hang, how high, and what feedline and common-mode problems come with it. Here is a framework for comparing the usual candidates.
Height and geometry come first. A horizontal wire at 25 to 35 ft is low for 80 and 40 m. It tends to radiate at high angles, which is fine for regional contacts and poor for DX. On 20 m and up, the same height starts to look reasonable. An inverted V, with its apex at the best support you have and its ends sloping down, saves horizontal space and needs only one tall support. The cost is a little pattern and bandwidth change and a feedpoint impedance that drops toward 50 ohms or below as the included angle closes. Trim for resonance by measurement, not by formula.
EFHW. The feedpoint of a half-wave wire at its end is high impedance, commonly in the low thousands of ohms depending on the installation. A 49:1 or 64:1 transformer brings that down toward 50 ohms. The advantages are one support, a single wire, and multiband operation on harmonically related bands (for example 40/20/15/10 from a 40 m wire). The catch is that an end-fed wire has no deliberate counterpoise, so the coax shield often becomes one. Without a common-mode choke, you may see SWR that changes when you move the coax, RF on the shack equipment, and noise pickup. A low SWR reading on an EFHW can be real or can be the feedline doing part of the radiating, so check it with a choke in place.
OCFD (Windom style). Feeding a half-wave wire about one third of the way along gives a more moderate impedance, often handled with a 4:1 current balun. It covers several bands, but the harmonic feedpoint impedances are not uniformly benign, and patterns on higher bands are lobed because the wire is multiple half-waves long. Balun core saturation and heating matter more at high SWR or high power.
G5RV and doublets. A G5RV is a 102 ft top with a ladder-line matching section, designed for good behavior on 20 m and tuner-assisted on other bands. A general doublet is any center-fed wire of roughly 100 to 130 ft or more, fed with open-wire or ladder line and used with a tuner that can handle balanced loads, or a good 4:1/1:1 balun-plus-tuner arrangement. Ladder line has very low loss even at high SWR, which is why a doublet can be the most flexible compromise. The real work is getting the line away from the house cleanly and choosing a length that avoids extreme impedances on your most-used bands.
Coax loss and SWR. A common mistake is treating SWR as a performance number. A dummy load is 1:1 and radiates nothing. Coax loss rises with frequency and with mismatch. Thin coax such as RG-58 loses noticeably more than RG-213 or low-loss 50 ohm cable at 14 MHz and above, and a high SWR on a long run multiplies the loss. If the tuner is at the radio and the antenna is a high-SWR multiband wire, the feedline matters more than the antenna model suggests.
Verticals. A vertical is a small-footprint option and can have a low takeoff angle. Its weakness is the ground system. A ground-mounted quarter-wave needs many radials, with 16 or more as a common rule of thumb for low loss. An elevated vertical can work with fewer resonant radials, often 2 to 4 per band. Sloping radials raise the feedpoint impedance toward 50 ohms. In a small yard, a vertical with a poor ground system can trade away the advantage of its low angle through ground loss.
Magnetic loops. A small loop can be a practical indoor, attic or balcony choice and often reduces local electrical noise. The tradeoff is efficiency, which depends heavily on loop diameter relative to wavelength, conductor loss and capacitor quality. Bandwidth is narrow, so you retune when you change frequency, and the loop's high voltage requires proper spacing and parts. Expect lower efficiency on 40 m and below, where a small loop is electrically very small.
Yagis. A multielement beam gives gain and front-to-back advantages, but it needs a tower or mast, a rotator and permission to put it up. For many HOA situations it is not on the table, and a good wire and a modest vertical are the realistic baseline.
Which tradeoffs have bitten people most in constrained installations: common-mode currents, ground losses, or tuner and feedline losses? And for HOA situations specifically, what has been the least visible practical option for you? Note that FCC PRB-1 covers state and local regulation, not private deed restrictions, so check your actual covenant text.
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11695-small-lot-or-hoa-efhw-ocfd-doublet-vertical-or-loop-what-actually-decides-the-result/Share on other sites