Choosing a handheld: FT-65R vs ID-52A vs TH-D75 (and where the IC-705 fits), plus CHIRP, offsets and emergency basics
- Replies 2
- Views 15
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Lee 1 post
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
Handheld questions tend to turn into brand arguments, so here is a framework. Please add corrections or your own preferences.
First, sort the radios into categories. The Yaesu FT-65R is a basic analog FM dual-band HT covering 2 m and 70 cm at around 5 W. It has no GPS, digital voice or Bluetooth, which keeps it simple. The Icom ID-52A is a dual-band D-STAR handheld with GPS and Bluetooth, and it can receive airband and other bands. The Kenwood TH-D75 is a tri-band (2 m, 1.25 m, 70 cm) with D-STAR, APRS and GPS. The Icom IC-705 is not a handheld in the usual sense. It is a compact portable transceiver covering HF, 6 m, VHF and UHF, with D-STAR support, and it is a better fit for portable HF operation than for clipping to a belt. The Baofeng line (UV-5R and similar) is the cheap, popular entry point for analog dual-band use.
Analog vs digital. D-STAR (Icom, and Kenwood on the TH-D75) needs a D-STAR repeater or hotspot nearby, plus callsign registration for gateway features. DMR is a separate system. It needs a DMR-capable radio (many are from other manufacturers), a DMR ID, a codeplug with the right color codes, time slots and talkgroups, and access to a DMR repeater or hotspot. Neither mode helps if there is no local activity, so check what your area has before paying for digital features. Analog FM works on nearly every repeater and on simplex.
Repeater offsets. Offsets and tones vary by region and band plan, so always check your local repeater directory. In the US, common conventions are 600 kHz on 2 m and 5 MHz on 70 cm, with the sign depending on the sub-band. The 1.25 m band commonly uses 1.6 MHz. Many repeaters also need a CTCSS (PL) tone on transmit. A frequent mistake is entering the output frequency correctly but forgetting the tone or using the wrong offset direction.
Programming with CHIRP. CHIRP is free and supports many analog radios, including Baofeng models and the FT-65R. Support for newer digital models can be limited or absent, and some radios need the manufacturer's software, so check CHIRP's supported-radio list before buying a cable. A typical workflow is to download the current configuration from the radio first and save it as a backup. Then import repeater data (for example from RepeaterBook) and edit memory names, tones and offsets. Upload only after reviewing. Cheap programming cables vary in quality, and a bad driver or connector is a common cause of failed transfers.
Batteries and antennas. A spare battery matters more than extra features for emergency use. Some radios offer an AA battery tray as a backup, but availability varies by model. Keep batteries charged and rotated, and know your charger's behavior. The stock rubber duck is a compromise. A longer whip or a roll-up J-pole can noticeably improve reach, but check the connector type (SMA-female versus SMA-male and so on), because it differs between radios. Cheap radios are also known to have spectral purity issues, which is worth considering where interference to other services is a concern.
Emergency use. A radio is only useful if you know how to use it before you need it. Practice with menus, store simplex and local repeater frequencies, and join local nets. Write your key frequencies and tones on a card in case the display or memory fails. Amateur transmitting requires a license in most countries. Receiving and listening do not.
What are you using now, and what is the main use: hiking, EmComm, local repeaters or digital modes?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11704-choosing-a-handheld-ft-65r-vs-id-52a-vs-th-d75-and-where-the-ic-705-fits-plus-chirp-offsets-and-emergency-basics/Share on other sites