Scratch-building wire dipoles and verticals: wire, chokes, support points, and how far to trust SWR and models
- Replies 2
- Views 14
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
-
Mod_Nancy 1 post
This thread is for the practical decisions that come up when you build an HF antenna from raw materials rather than buying a kit. I'll start with a rough order of operations, and then I'd like to hear where others disagree.
Start with the support plan, not the wire length. The wire length can be trimmed, but the places where you can hang things cannot. Decide the apex or center height, where the ends will land, and how the feedline will leave the antenna. A dipole at 30 to 40 feet is a very different antenna from one at 15 feet, and the resonant length shifts with height, nearby trees, and wire insulation. The familiar 468/f(MHz) formula gives a half-wave length in feet. For 7.1 MHz that is about 66 feet total, so each leg is about 33 feet. Treat that as a starting point. Cut long, fold the excess back at the ends, measure, and prune.
For wire, 14 AWG hard-drawn copper is a common choice for long permanent spans, because it resists stretching. Soft-drawn copper stretches over time and moves your resonance. Copper-clad steel is strong, but it has more skin-effect loss at lower frequencies, and it can be stiff and springy. Insulated stranded wire is easy to handle and lowers the resonant frequency a few percent compared with bare wire, so allow for that. Wire gauge matters less for efficiency than most people expect at HF. A dipole made from 14 AWG instead of 18 AWG will have slightly broader bandwidth and better mechanical life, but it won't be dramatically stronger on the air. What fails in the field is usually the connection or the strain relief, not the conductor.
Insulators and supports are where many builds fail. Use UV-resistant polyester or similar low-stretch rope at the ends. Avoid cotton, which rots, and cheap nylon, which stretches and weakens in sunlight. The center insulator should take the wire tension, not the solder joint or the coax connector. Run the wire through the holes, twist it back, and then solder, so the joint carries no load. The coax should hang from a strain-relief point, because its weight pulls on the center. A fiberglass pole at the center or ends is useful because it doesn't detune the antenna the way a metal mast does. Poles flex, so leave some slack for wind loading.
Feedline and common-mode current deserve separate attention. A coax-fed dipole should have a 1:1 current balun or choke at the feedpoint. The goal is to keep RF off the outside of the shield, and a choke with high impedance does this better than a low-loss one. Ferrite beads or toroids of a suitable mix, such as type 31 or 43 in many builds, wound with several turns of coax, are one common approach. Another is a coiled-coax choke, which works but tends to be narrower in bandwidth. If you feed the dipole with 450-ohm window line instead, you can use it on multiple bands with a tuner, but keep the line away from metal gutters and walls, and expect a balun or choke at the transition into the shack.
Verticals have their own questions. A quarter-wave vertical for 20 m is about 16.5 feet, which fits nicely on a telescoping fiberglass pole with wire taped along it. The radial system matters more than the radiator. Raised radials, sloped or horizontal, can be fewer and resonant; ground-mounted radials usually need more, and many people use a larger quantity of mixed lengths. The feedpoint impedance changes with radial angle and count, which is why the SWR varies from the textbook number.
Finally, how much do you trust a low SWR? It tells you the match at the point of measurement, not how much power is being radiated. Coax loss can make a poor antenna look good, and a modeled pattern can look wonderful if the ground or segmentation is wrong. What methods do you use to confirm that an antenna works, rather than just matches?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11708-scratch-building-wire-dipoles-and-verticals-wire-chokes-support-points-and-how-far-to-trust-swr-and-models/Share on other sites