2m/70cm antenna choices: whip, J-pole, collinear or yagi, and what actually matters once it's installed
- Replies 2
- Views 18
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
This is a starting point for comparing common VHF/UHF antenna types on practical terms rather than catalog gain numbers. Most problems with 2 m and 70 cm stations come from the installation (feedline, connectors, ground plane, polarization, height) rather than from the antenna type.
Simple verticals. A quarter-wave whip is about 19 inches on 2 m and about 6.5 inches on 70 cm. It is mechanically simple and tolerant of imperfect ground planes, and its pattern is very predictable. A 5/8-wave whip has a lower takeoff angle and a few dB more gain than a quarter-wave under good conditions, but it needs a matching coil or network at the base and a reasonable ground plane to perform as advertised. On a small mag mount or a roof-edge NMO mount the real pattern can be skewed, and the gain on paper may never show up. A 5/8 whip on a metal roof is a good match. The same whip on a fiberglass trunk lid with a tiny ground plane is a poor one.
J-pole and Slim Jim. Both are end-fed half-wave antennas with a quarter-wave matching section. Their gain is close to a half-wave dipole, so expect roughly 0 dBd and not the 3 dB or more some listings claim. They need no radials, which is why they are popular for DIY builds from twin-lead, copper pipe or ladder line. The catch is that with no ground plane, the coax shield can carry common-mode current and become part of the radiator. A choke (ferrite beads or a few turns of coax) near the feedpoint often improves pattern consistency, and the SWR may change when you move the cable. The Slim Jim is a folded variant of the J-pole. Its pattern and gain are similar, with a slightly lower radiation angle in many builds.
Collinears. Stacking phased elements squeezes the vertical pattern, trading elevation coverage for horizon gain. That helps for a base station talking across flat terrain. It hurts when you are in hills or in a tall building looking down at a nearby repeater, because the main lobe can pass over the target. Collinear gain figures depend heavily on whether they are quoted in dBi or dBd, a 2.15 dB difference. Check the unit before comparing.
Yagis. A directional antenna adds gain and rejects interference from the sides and rear. Typical 2 m yagis range from about 6 to 12 dBd depending on boom length. The tradeoff is that you have to aim it. For FM repeater work, mount it with the elements vertical. For weak-signal SSB/CW, convention is horizontal polarization. A cross-polarized path can cost many dB, and the actual loss in real terrain varies a lot.
Feedline and connectors. At 440 MHz, coax loss adds up quickly. RG-58 loses several dB per 100 ft on 70 cm, while low-loss types like LMR-400 or RG-213 class cables lose far less. Check the manufacturer's datasheet for the exact cable. A PL-259 is acceptable for 2 m and many mobile installs, but its impedance isn't constant and weatherproofing is poor. An N-type connector has a controlled 50 ohm design, seals better with proper tape or boots, and is the better choice for outdoor UHF runs. Adapters add loss and failure points, so minimize them.
SWR. A low SWR means the antenna's impedance matches the line. It does not prove the antenna is radiating efficiently. A dummy load has a perfect SWR and zero gain. Lossy coax can make a poor antenna look better, because the reflected power is attenuated on its way back to the meter. For a meaningful tuning check, measure at the antenna end if you can, or use a short test cable.
Repeater and satellite use. A repeater site needs omnidirectional vertical coverage, good isolation between transmit and receive antennas or a duplexer, and low-loss hardline. For a user trying to reach a distant repeater, a small yagi can help far more than a taller whip. For low-earth-orbit satellites, a handheld dual-band yagi works for FM passes, and the operator has to track the satellite and account for polarization changes. Fixed station setups often use crossed yagis with circular polarization and an az/el rotator.
Questions to get things started: what are you trying to reach, what is the terrain, and what mounting options do you have? What would you check first when a new install shows high SWR or weak signals?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11712-2m70cm-antenna-choices-whip-j-pole-collinear-or-yagi-and-what-actually-matters-once-its-installed/Share on other sites