Planning a dual-band mobile install: FTM-500D vs ID-5100A vs TM-D710G, plus wiring, noise and etiquette
- Replies 2
- Views 15
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
This thread is for working through a 2 meter / 70 centimeter mobile setup from the radio choice through to on-air habits. The three radios that come up most often for this are the Yaesu FTM-500D, the Icom ID-5100A and the Kenwood TM-D710G. They are all FM dual-band mobiles with digital or data features, but they suit different operators.
Radio choice. The FTM-500D is a Yaesu System Fusion (C4FM) radio, so it makes sense if your local repeaters and friends are on Fusion. The ID-5100A is an Icom D-STAR radio with a touchscreen, and its appeal is largely D-STAR plus the dual-receive layout. The TM-D710G is the one people tend to pick for APRS, with a built-in TNC and a long history of use as a mobile packet and tracking station. Before buying, check which digital mode your area actually uses, because a digital mode nobody nearby uses is just an expensive FM radio. Also check the manual for the specific features you need. Not every mobile offers cross-band repeat, and the way each one handles it differs.
Cross-band repeat. The idea is that the mobile receives on one band and retransmits on the other. A common use is a handheld on 70 cm talking through the vehicle's rig and its roof antenna on 2 meters. It is useful at a trailhead, a work site or an event, but it needs some care. Check your local rules on control operator, station identification and any restrictions on this mode. Make sure the transmit and receive frequencies are far enough apart and the antennas separated enough that you are not desensing yourself, and remember a vehicle repeating at 50 W can run warm if you leave it keyed up for long periods. Read the radio's own cross-band instructions, including how to turn it off, so you do not leave it running by mistake.
Mounting. Put the main body where it will not be hit by knees, cargo or airbag deployment, and keep the head unit where you can glance at it without reaching. Many installs use under-seat or console mounting with the control head remote-mounted on radios that support it. Mount the microphone hanger somewhere you can reach it without looking. Whatever you do, do not drill into or fasten to anything you have not checked behind first.
Power and fusing. A 50 W FM mobile can draw on the order of ten amps or more on high power, so do not use a cigarette lighter socket. Run properly sized wire directly from the battery or a suitable fused distribution point, put a fuse on the positive lead close to the source, and use the fuses and gauge the manufacturer specifies. Use a grommet where the cable passes through the firewall so it cannot chafe. Some modern vehicles monitor battery current on the negative terminal, so check the vehicle manual before choosing the ground point. Keep the ground connection short, on clean bare metal, and tight.
Antenna and coax. A roof-center NMO mount with a dual-band antenna is the usual choice. Coax loss climbs on 70 cm, so use a decent low-loss cable rather than the thinnest stuff available, and check SWR on both bands after installing. A poor ground plane or a bad connector can make an antenna look fine on one band and bad on the other.
Noise. Work out whether the noise is on receive or transmit. Alternator whine usually shows up as a tone that follows engine RPM, and it can come through the power lead or into the audio. Ignition and electronic noise tends to be a hash or ticking on receive. Test with accessories off, then switch them on one at a time, since LED lighting, USB chargers and DC-DC converters are common offenders. Keep power wiring away from coax, use ferrites where they help, and make sure the grounds are solid before buying any filters.
Etiquette. Listen before you key up, keep transmissions short, and use a hands-free setup or pull over when traffic needs your attention. Follow your local laws on handheld devices while driving. Do not hog a busy repeater, and if you are on APRS or digital modes, think about what your beacon rate and settings are doing to everyone else on the channel.
What would you prioritise first: the radio, the antenna or the power wiring? And has anyone found a clean way to route the control head and mic cable so the install still looks tidy?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11741-planning-a-dual-band-mobile-install-ftm-500d-vs-id-5100a-vs-tm-d710g-plus-wiring-noise-and-etiquette/Share on other sites