Small lot, HOA rules, 80m through 10m: EFHW vs. doublet vs. compromise vertical, and where the losses really are
- Replies 2
- Views 13
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Terry 1 post
-
Mod_Tom 1 post
Here is a common scenario, and a useful way to compare designs. You have a roughly 50 x 100 ft lot, no tower, and an HOA that objects to anything that looks like an antenna. Say you can get thin wire up to about 30 to 35 ft at one end, with a tree or the roofline as a second support. You want to operate 40m through 10m, and 80m would be nice but isn't essential. The usual candidates are an end-fed half-wave (EFHW), a doublet or G5RV-style antenna with a tuner, an OCFD, or a ground-mounted or roof-mounted vertical.
Before comparing them, it helps to separate three things that often get blurred: SWR, feedline loss, and radiation efficiency. A low SWR at the radio only means the load is near 50 ohms at that point. It says nothing about how much power is radiated. A dummy load has a perfect SWR. A very short antenna with lossy matching can also show a flat SWR and still be a poor radiator.
EFHW: The feedpoint of a half-wave wire is high impedance, typically a few thousand ohms, so these antennas use a 49:1 or 64:1 transformer (often called an unun). That is convenient: one wire, one small box, and it can run as an inverted-L or sloper. The usual weak points are the transformer's core loss and the lack of a defined counterpoise. The coax shield often becomes part of the antenna. A common-mode choke at the radio end of the coax is cheap insurance, and so is making the radiating wire as high as the lot allows. A multiband EFHW is resonant on the fundamental and its harmonics (for example 40/20/15/10m). The 17m, 12m, and 30m bands usually depend on the transformer's design or a tuner.
Doublet / G5RV / ladder-line fed: A center-fed wire fed with balanced line and a tuner is the most flexible HF option for a small lot, and it is hard to beat when the antenna isn't resonant everywhere. The ladder line has very low loss even at high SWR, and the tuner sits at the radio. The standard G5RV is a 102 ft flat-top with a roughly 31 ft matching section into coax. It was designed with 20m in mind, and on other bands it relies on the tuner. A half-size 51 ft version covers 40m up, though 40m can be awkward. If you are going to use a tuner anyway, a plain doublet of random length fed with ladder line often beats a G5RV with its coax run, because the high-SWR section of the feedline is the low-loss part.
OCFD: The off-center feed (around 1/3 to 1/4 along the wire) with a 4:1 current balun gives a reasonable match on several harmonically related bands. The patterns on the higher bands are more lobed than a plain dipole's. The balun is doing the work, and cheap ones can overheat or lose a lot of power at awkward impedances.
Vertical: A quarter-wave vertical gives low takeoff angles for DX but needs a good radial system. A handful of short buried radials can lose a large share of the power in ground resistance. Elevated radials, even four tuned ones, are often more efficient than a similar number laid on the ground. A short loaded vertical on a roof or deck makes the efficiency problem worse. A vertical also tends to pick up more local noise than a horizontal wire.
Two numbers are worth keeping in mind. First, height: a horizontal dipole at 30 ft is only about 0.22 wavelength high on 40m, so it tends to radiate at high angles, good for regional contacts and less so for DX. On 20m and up the same height is better. Second, coax loss rises quickly with frequency, and it rises again with mismatch. As a rough guide, RG-58 loses around 1 dB per 100 ft on 20m when matched, and more on 10m. Heavier coax like RG-213 is better. A high-SWR path through lossy coax is where a lot of 'my antenna tunes up fine' power disappears.
So the question is not which antenna is best in general, but which problem you are trying to solve. For people short on both space and visibility, what does the trade look like between a ladder-fed doublet (more wire up, more flexibility) and an EFHW (simpler to feed, harder to control common-mode current)? And how much does a magnetic loop belong in the conversation for an HOA situation, given its narrow bandwidth and the efficiency penalty at 40m and 80m?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11766-small-lot-hoa-rules-80m-through-10m-efhw-vs-doublet-vs-compromise-vertical-and-where-the-losses-really-are/Share on other sites