Dual-band mobile setup: FTM-500D vs ID-5100A vs TM-D710G, plus wiring, noise and cross-band repeat
- Replies 2
- Views 12
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
I'm starting a thread for anyone planning or fixing a 2 meter / 70 cm mobile install. The three radios that come up most for a new dual-band mobile are the Yaesu FTM-500D, the Icom ID-5100A and the Kenwood TM-D710G. All three are roughly 50 W class FM radios with dual-band operation. Where they differ is digital mode support, built-in extras and how you interact with them while driving.
Rough orientation, so we can correct each other:
Before anyone picks a winner, a question that matters more than brand: what do your local repeaters actually run? A radio with a mode you never use is a lot of money for a nice display. If your area is mostly analog FM with a few digital machines, the analog performance, controls and ergonomics matter more than the feature list.
Here are the install topics I'd like the thread to cover, in the order I'd tackle them:
1. Power wiring. Run power directly to the battery with the fused leads that come with the radio, rather than to a cigarette lighter socket or an accessory fuse block that was never meant for sustained transmit current. A 50 W FM transmission draws on the order of a dozen amps, so the factory cable and fuse are sized for that. Keep the fuse holder close to the battery terminal, protect both the positive and negative leads if the cable includes two fuses, and use a grommet where the cable passes through the firewall so the insulation doesn't chafe on sheet metal. Please don't extend the cable with lighter-gauge wire.
2. Mounting. The radio body needs to be solid, away from airbags and knee or head strike zones, and out of direct sun. These radios shed heat through the case and rear heatsink, so don't wrap the body in carpet or stuff it under a pile of gear. With a separable control head, pick a position that lets you operate with minimal glance time.
3. Antenna and coax. A roof-center NMO mount with a dual-band antenna is the classic starting point. A magnetic mount is easier but depends on a good ground plane and clean contact. Coax loss is bigger at 70 cm than at 2 meters, so a long run of thin cable hurts more on UHF. Check SWR on both bands rather than only on 2 meters.
4. Noise. Alternator whine, ignition noise and hash from LED lighting or DC-DC converters are the usual suspects. Work from the simplest causes outward: check the ground connections, keep the power cable away from noisy harnesses, and test with and without other accessories running. Ferrite chokes can help on certain leads but don't replace fixing a poor ground.
5. Cross-band repeat. This is where you receive a signal on one band, such as a handheld on UHF, and the mobile retransmits it on the other band. It is useful for a handheld that can't reach a repeater from where you're standing. Don't assume every radio does it, and check the manual and current firmware notes for your exact model. Make sure the setup keeps you within your license privileges, with a valid control operator and proper station identification.
So: which of the three would you pick for a first mobile, and what part of the install do people most often get wrong?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11786-dual-band-mobile-setup-ftm-500d-vs-id-5100a-vs-tm-d710g-plus-wiring-noise-and-cross-band-repeat/Share on other sites