VHF/UHF antenna choices: J-pole vs. collinear vs. 5/8 wave vs. yagi, and what coax, connectors and SWR actually tell you
- Replies 2
- Views 12
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Mod_Tom 1 post
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
Antenna threads on VHF/UHF often turn into "which one has the most gain," but the better question is where you need the energy to go. A vehicle, a home base station, a repeater site and a satellite pass all reward different designs. Here is a framework to argue with.
Gain is pattern shaping, not free power. Gain figures are only meaningful with a reference. dBd is relative to a half-wave dipole and dBi is relative to an isotropic radiator, with dBi = dBd + 2.15. A vertical omni has no horizontal directivity, so its gain comes from squashing the pattern flatter toward the horizon. A longer collinear or 5/8-wave stack sends more energy at low angles and less up and down. That helps with distant stations on flat terrain. It can hurt when you are close to a repeater on a hill, or in a valley with steep angles to the signal, because you may be sitting in a shallow null of your own pattern.
Quarter-wave whip. At 2 m a quarter wave is roughly 19 to 20 inches, and at 70 cm it is about 6.5 inches. It is simple, mechanically tough and has a low-angle pattern. It needs a decent ground plane, which on a vehicle means the roof. It is near 50 ohms with no matching network, so there is little to go wrong. Gain is about unity over a quarter-wave reference, so you give up a little for ruggedness and easy fitting.
5/8 wave. At 2 m this is around 48 to 50 inches, with a loading coil or matching network at the base. Typical claims are about 3 dB over a quarter-wave, and the pattern is lower and flatter. The catch is that the matching network and ground plane matter a lot. A 5/8 on a small or poorly grounded surface can show a decent SWR yet radiate with a tilted, distorted pattern. Where the ground plane is small, such as a trunk lip or a small mag mount on a thin roof, the shorter antenna is often the less fussy one.
J-pole and Slim Jim. Both are end-fed half-wave antennas with a quarter-wave matching section. The J-pole has the familiar J shape. The Slim Jim is a folded variant with a lower radiation angle and a bit more apparent gain. They need no radials, which is why people like them for attic, balcony or temporary use. But "no radials" does not mean the feedline stays out of the system. Without a choke, common-mode current can flow on the outside of the coax and shift the pattern and the SWR reading. A few turns of coax into a coil, or ferrite beads, at the feedpoint helps. These are also often built from twin-lead or copper pipe, which makes them cheap but dependent on a careful build for the matching dimensions.
Collinears. These stack phased half-wave sections to flatten the pattern and build omni gain. Claimed gain of 6 to 9 dBi is common on commercial designs, but the actual figure depends on length, quality of the phasing sections and feedpoint matching. They want to be mounted away from the mast, ideally at the top, or on a side arm that holds them several feet clear of metal. Too close, and the mast becomes part of the antenna.
Yagis. A yagi trades coverage for directivity. More elements on a longer boom narrow the beamwidth, raise forward gain and improve front-to-back ratio. This suits point-to-point work, a distant repeater, weak-signal SSB/CW and some satellite use. The cost is a rotator or manual pointing, plus a more sensitive installation. Weak-signal work is usually horizontally polarized, while FM repeaters and simplex are vertical, so check which one you actually need. Cross-polarized, you can lose 20 dB or so, although real-world reflections reduce that loss.
Mobile mounting: NMO vs. mag mount. NMO uses a 3/4 inch hole in the roof and gives the best electrical and mechanical connection, and the whips are interchangeable. A mag mount needs no drilling, but the coupling relies on the paint and magnet contact, the cable must run through a door or window gasket without being pinched, and a cheap one can slide or scratch at speed. Roof center is the best position for a symmetrical pattern. A mount at the edge of the vehicle gives a lopsided pattern, with the body shadowing one side.
Coax and connectors. Loss increases with frequency and length. Very roughly, RG-58 loses about 4 to 5 dB per 100 ft at 150 MHz and nearly double that at 450 MHz. RG-213 or LMR-400-type cable is much better, around 1.5 to 2 dB per 100 ft at 2 m and a bit under 4 dB at 70 cm, depending on the cable. A 6 dB gain collinear plus 5 dB of loss on a long thin cable is a poor trade. PL-259/SO-239 (UHF connectors) are fine on 2 m for moderate power, but they are not constant impedance and are not as good on 70 cm and above. N-type connectors are constant impedance, better sealed and a sensible choice for permanent outdoor use. All outdoor connections should be weatherproofed with proper tape or sealing, and the coax should have a drip loop so water does not run into the connector.
SWR. Low SWR means the transmitter sees a good match. It does not mean the antenna is radiating well. A dummy load has an excellent SWR and radiates nothing. Lossy coax can also hide a bad antenna, since reflected power is attenuated on its way back. Whenever possible, check the antenna with a short jumper or an analyzer at the feedpoint, and sweep the whole band, not just one frequency.
Repeater and satellite specifics. A repeater antenna system must cope with transmit/receive separation, duplexers, isolation and a pattern sized for the coverage area, which is why you see omnis with controlled downtilt. Satellite antennas have different problems. LEO satellites move quickly and their orientation changes, so circular polarization (crossed yagis, turnstiles, helicals) reduces fading, although hand-held directional yagis with linear polarization are often used on FM satellites with manual polarization rotation. You also need the right balance of gain and beamwidth, because a very narrow beam is hard to keep pointed at a satellite crossing the sky.
What are you trying to cover: local repeaters, simplex, a long path, satellites or all of the above? And is the antenna going on a car, a roof or a mast? That decides most of the choice.
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11798-vhfuhf-antenna-choices-j-pole-vs-collinear-vs-58-wave-vs-yagi-and-what-coax-connectors-and-swr-actually-tell-you/Share on other sites