Dual-band mobile rigs: FTM-500D vs ID-5100A vs TM-D710G, plus wiring, noise and mobile etiquette
- Replies 2
- Views 12
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
This thread is for sorting out what matters when you put a 2 meter / 70 centimeter mobile in a vehicle. Three radios come up constantly: the Yaesu FTM-500D, the Icom ID-5100A and the Kenwood TM-D710G. They all put out roughly 50 watts on VHF and UHF, but they differ in digital modes, APRS support, control head design and features like cross-band repeat. Specs change and variants differ by region, so check each manufacturer's current manual and spec sheet before buying.
Some starting points for discussion:
Choosing a radio. The FTM-500D is built around Yaesu's C4FM digital voice (System Fusion) alongside analog FM. The ID-5100A is a D-STAR radio with a touchscreen and dual receive. The TM-D710G has a built-in TNC and GPS aimed at APRS, and it is often discussed for its cross-band repeat function. Before comparing menus, decide which digital mode your local repeaters actually use. A radio that does a mode nobody near you uses is mostly a very good analog FM rig. Also check whether you want a separable control head. That depends on the model and usually requires an optional cable or kit, so confirm what your exact model supports.
Power wiring and fusing. The usual advice is to run power directly to the battery, not to a cigarette lighter socket or an accessory circuit. Put a fuse in the positive lead as close to the battery terminal as practical, so that a chafed wire anywhere along the run is protected. Use the wire gauge and fuse rating given in your radio's manual, because it accounts for transmit current and cable length. Protect the cable with a rubber grommet where it passes through the firewall, avoid sharp metal edges, and route it away from moving parts and hot components. Many radios also have fuses in their own power cable, which should stay in place.
Mounting. Pick a spot that doesn't interfere with airbag deployment, pedals, or your ability to see and reach the controls without taking your eyes off the road. A bracket bolted to something solid is better than adhesive pads on trim. Leave room behind the radio for airflow, since a 50 W transmitter makes heat during longer transmissions.
Antenna and noise. Most mobile noise problems turn out to be antenna or grounding problems, or interference from the vehicle's own electronics. A roof-center NMO mount with a dual-band antenna is a common setup. Trunk-lip and magnetic mounts can work but depend heavily on a good ground connection to the body. Check SWR on both bands, since an antenna can look fine on 2 meters and be poor on 70 cm. Coax loss matters more at UHF, so don't use a long, cheap run if you can avoid it. For noise, compare the receiver with the engine off, at idle and while revving. Alternator whine that follows engine speed points toward power-lead filtering or routing. Ignition and electronic noise can come from LED lighting, aftermarket chargers and DC-DC converters. Ferrite chokes on power leads, moving the radio's cable away from other wiring and checking the ground path are all worth trying one at a time.
Cross-band repeat. This lets a mobile radio receive on one band and retransmit on the other, so a handheld outside the vehicle can reach a repeater through the mobile's better antenna and power. Not every radio supports it, so check the manual for your exact model. It also raises licensing and operating questions: you remain responsible for identification and for operating within your license privileges and local regulations, and the transmitter is working harder than in normal use. Where are people drawing the line on when it is appropriate?
Etiquette. Driving comes first. Keep transmissions short, pre-program your memories so you aren't navigating menus on the move, and know your local rules on handheld device use while driving. On repeaters, listen before you transmit, leave a gap so others can break in, identify properly, and give priority to emergency traffic. Set your APRS beacon rate sensibly so you don't clutter the channel.
What would you put on a must-do checklist for a first mobile install, and what mistakes do you see most often?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11822-dual-band-mobile-rigs-ftm-500d-vs-id-5100a-vs-tm-d710g-plus-wiring-noise-and-mobile-etiquette/Share on other sites