Run vs. S&P vs. chasing mults: how do you decide when to leave a good run frequency?
- Replies 2
- Views 7
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
-
Mod_Nancy 1 post
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
A question that comes up in almost every contest debrief: when is it right to leave a frequency that is producing a decent rate to go hunt multipliers, and when is it just wasted time? Here is a framework to get the discussion going, and I'd like to hear where people think it breaks down.
The multiplier math. In a typical contest, score is roughly (QSO points) x (multipliers). If every QSO is worth the same number of points, one additional multiplier is worth about N/M QSOs, where N is your current QSO count and M is your current multiplier count. With 1,500 QSOs and 300 multipliers, a new multiplier is worth about five average QSOs. Early in the contest, or on a band where you still need many mults, a new one is worth less in QSO terms than it feels like. Late in the contest, when M is nearly saturated, chasing the last few mults costs a lot of time for a small return. This ignores per-band multipliers, where a new mult on a new band counts again, so the value of a band change depends heavily on the rules of the contest in question. It also assumes equal QSO values. Where DX contacts are worth several times a domestic one, the equation changes.
Rate comparison. A cleaner way to think about it is to compare your sustained run rate against what you expect to gain from the excursion. If you are running 90 Q/hr and spend four minutes tuning for a mult, you gave up about six QSOs plus whatever happens to your frequency while you were away. If the mult is worth five QSOs and the frequency is still yours when you return, you roughly broke even. If someone sat on your frequency while you were gone, you lost much more. Skimmer spots and a good bandmap make the trip cheaper because you go straight to a known station rather than tuning blind.
Where S&P wins. Search and pounce is usually the better choice when your run rate has collapsed (the band is closing, or the path to your best multiplier-rich areas is closing), when you are low power and calling CQ yields little, or when the bandmap is stocked with needed multipliers. It is also the natural way to get on a new band quickly: tune the bandmap, work the strongest stations, and find out whether the band is worth a CQ before committing to it.
Where running wins. A steady run with a clean frequency tends to beat S&P in raw Q/hr by a wide margin for stations with decent antennas and power. Some of that advantage is just that running keeps you transmitting rather than listening. Most operators' best hours come from a good run on the right band at the right time, not from hunting.
Band changes. Band choice by time of day matters more than almost any other decision. A rough approach is to plan the major band transitions in advance from propagation expectations, then let observed conditions (skimmer spot density, what you can hear, what's active on the bandmap) override the plan. It's easy to stay on a band too long because the rate there is still acceptable, even though the next band would produce a better one.
Questions for the thread:
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11839-run-vs-sp-vs-chasing-mults-how-do-you-decide-when-to-leave-a-good-run-frequency/Share on other sites