I've been using a straight key for about 6 months and can copy around 12-13 WPM reasonably well. Just got my first paddle (Whiterook MK-44) and I'm struggling with the transition. My timing feels completely off and I keep making extra dits when I don't mean to.

Any tips for making this transition smoother? Should I drop back down in speed while learning the paddle mechanics, or try to maintain my current speed? Many clubs recommend starting with a straight key to learn the fundamentals, but if you're aiming for faster proficiency, a paddle might be a better long-term investment.

Learning Morse code for CW operation takes diligence, and the more time you devote to learning, the greater likelihood of improving and enjoying it more. Definitely drop your speed back to around 8-10 WPM while you get comfortable with the paddle mechanics. Focus on clean characters first, speed will come naturally.

I went through this exact same thing! After using a straight key, a paddle takes practice to get used to the sideways movement and timing, but with a little practice it becomes second nature. Try practicing common letter combinations like 'AR', 'SK', and your callsign over and over until the muscle memory kicks in.

Check if your keyer has Iambic Mode A (completes the element being sent when paddles are released) vs Mode B (sends an additional element opposite to the one being sent when paddles are released). Many newcomers find Mode A more forgiving while learning. Also, make sure your paddle tension isn't too sensitive - that can cause unwanted extra dits.