I'm looking to get into conversational digital modes and torn between JS8Call and PSK31. I understand JS8Call has replaced PSK31 as the primary keyboard mode, though 20M PSK31 still has activity. JS8Call takes FT8's robustness but adds messaging and free-form text capability, while PSK31 offers narrow 31 Hz bandwidth and real-time typing.

For someone new to digital conversations, which would you recommend? I've read JS8Call can be complex to set up but has better weak-signal performance.

I've been making excellent PSK31 contacts lately - most are macro-based but real keyboard conversations do happen. Both modes allow proper conversations if that's your style, but PSK31 is more straightforward to learn.

As a newer operator, I started with JS8Call because I was already familiar with WSJT-X from FT8. The messaging layer lets you chat off-grid during emergencies - very appealing for EMCOMM applications.

Getting FLdigi working with my SDR setup was challenging initially, but once configured it opens up many more modes beyond just PSK31. JS8Call is more sensitive to linearity than FT8/FT4, so your transmitter setup matters more.