Small-yard HF antennas: comparing EFHW, OCFD, doublet, vertical and loop by what the SWR meter can't tell you
- Replies 2
- Views 43
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
Many small-yard and HOA antenna threads end up as a contest over whose SWR curve is flattest. That reading only tells you how well the transmitter is matched at the shack end. It says nothing about how much power reaches the air, or at what angle. A dummy load has a perfect SWR and radiates nothing.
Take a typical constrained lot: one or two supports around 30 to 40 ft, a run of 60 to 100 ft to the shack, no room for a full-size 80 m dipole, and a neighbor or covenant that makes anything obvious a problem. These are the questions I'd want to settle before choosing an antenna.
First, what is the feedpoint doing? An end-fed half-wave (EFHW) presents a few thousand ohms at the end of the wire, so it needs a transformer of roughly 49:1 or 64:1 and some counterpoise. On many installs that counterpoise is the outside of the coax, so a common-mode choke at the feedpoint matters. An off-center-fed dipole (OCFD) uses a 4:1 or similar balun and relies on harmonic behavior, and its pattern gets lumpy on some bands. A doublet on ladder line with a tuner has few mysteries, but you need a decent balun or choke at the tuner and a plan for bringing the line into the shack.
Second, where does the loss hide? Coax loss is small on a matched low-band run but climbs with SWR. RG-213 is typically around 0.6 dB per 100 ft at 14 MHz when matched, and thinner coax like RG-58 loses well over twice that, so check the manufacturer's table. A G5RV is a good example: it was designed around a 3/2-wave on 20 m, and elsewhere the ladder-line section transforms the impedance into something the tuner has to fix. If the line then runs through 70 ft of coax at high SWR, the loss can be significant on the higher bands.
Third, height and takeoff angle. A horizontal dipole at 0.25 wavelength or lower leans toward high-angle radiation, which is fine for regional work and not so good for DX. On 40 m, 35 ft is only about 0.25 wavelength. An inverted V at that apex height is a fair compromise, but keep the included angle at 90 degrees or more and keep the ends well out of reach, since the voltage there is high.
Fourth, the ground system on verticals. A ground-mounted vertical with a handful of short radials can lose a large share of power as heat in the soil. Many short radials, or a few resonant elevated radials, usually give better results than a bigger radiator over poor ground.
Magnetic loops and trap dipoles each have their own bargain. A small loop has a narrow bandwidth and a high-Q capacitor, and its efficiency depends heavily on conductor resistance and joint quality, so it can be quiet on receive but weak on 40 m or 80 m. Traps shorten a dipole but add loss and narrow its bandwidth on each band.
On the HOA side, in the US the FCC's PRB-1 asks local governments to reasonably accommodate amateur antennas, but it does not override private deed restrictions, so read the actual covenant text. What are people weighing most when deciding between a wire in the trees, a flagpole-style vertical, or a loop: efficiency, visibility, or noise?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/10791-small-yard-hf-antennas-comparing-efhw-ocfd-doublet-vertical-and-loop-by-what-the-swr-meter-cant-tell-you/Share on other sites