Dual-band mobile rigs (FTM-500D, ID-5100A, TM-D710G): what matters in the install, and what to check before relying on cross-band repeat
- Replies 2
- Views 36
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
This thread is for comparing notes on 2 meter / 70 centimeter mobile setups. The three rigs that come up most often for a new install are the Yaesu FTM-500D, the Icom ID-5100A and the Kenwood TM-D710G. All three are dual-band FM mobiles in the 50-watt class, but they are built around different ideas. The FTM-500D is a Yaesu System Fusion (C4FM) radio with analog FM. The ID-5100A is a D-STAR radio with a touchscreen head and analog FM. The TM-D710G is an analog FM radio that puts its emphasis on APRS, with a built-in TNC and a GPS interface. Which one fits depends on what is active on your local repeaters, and on whether you care about digital voice, APRS or just a dependable FM rig.
Here are a few topics to get the discussion going.
1. Mounting and head placement. All three use a separate control head and body, so the body can go under a seat, behind a console or in a trunk while the head sits where you can reach it. The usual mistakes are blocking the heat sink or fan airflow, mounting the body where it can slide into cargo, and putting the head where it interferes with an airbag deployment zone. Mount the body to something solid with screws, not just hook-and-loop tape or double-sided foam. Leave service loops on the control cable and mic cable so nothing is under tension when the seat moves.
2. Power wiring and fusing. The common advice is to run power directly from the battery, with a fuse in the positive lead close to the battery terminal. The fuse protects the wire, so it belongs at the source end. Use the fuse holders supplied with the radio, but check the fuse rating against the manual for your model. Keep the wire gauge adequate for the run length and the rig's peak transmit current. Use a proper grommet where the cable passes through the firewall, and avoid sharp metal edges. A fused distribution block is an alternative if you have several accessories. Switching the radio through an ignition-controlled relay is a reasonable option if you do not want the rig live all the time, but it should not be a way to power the radio through a thin existing circuit.
3. Noise suppression. Start with the antenna, since a poor ground plane or a marginal coax connection will make a noisy install look worse. Then identify the source. Alternator whine usually changes with engine speed. Ignition noise ticks along with the engine. Aftermarket LED lighting, USB chargers, dash cams and DC-DC converters are common offenders even with the engine off. Try turning accessories off one at a time while listening on a quiet frequency. If power-line noise is the problem, ferrite chokes on the DC leads and a clean, short path to the battery can help. Routing the power cable away from the vehicle's other wiring can too.
4. Cross-band repeat. This feature lets the mobile receive on one band and retransmit on the other, which is handy for extending a handheld's reach from outside the vehicle. Do not assume every dual-band mobile supports it, or that it works the same way on every model. Check the manual for the specific rig and firmware before you buy with this in mind. Also check the identification and control-operator rules that apply in your country, because an unattended cross-band setup is still your transmitter. Antenna separation matters too, since a handheld sitting close to the vehicle antenna can cause desense.
5. Mobile etiquette. Keep transmissions short and listen before keying. Let the repeater drop between exchanges so others can join. Remember that driving comes first: use a hands-free mic or voice-friendly workflow where it is legal, and pull over for anything that needs your attention. Check your local laws on handheld and in-vehicle device use, since they vary.
Questions to answer below: Which of these radios has the most practical head-unit layout for you? What was the toughest noise source to track down? And has anyone compared how the digital modes behave in a mobile environment versus plain analog FM?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/10793-dual-band-mobile-rigs-ftm-500d-id-5100a-tm-d710g-what-matters-in-the-install-and-what-to-check-before-relying-on-cross-band-repeat/Share on other sites