Small lot, HOA, 80m–10m: how to rank EFHW, OCFD, doublet, inverted V and loaded verticals by efficiency rather than SWR
- Replies 2
- Views 96
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
A common setup question: a 50 x 100 ft lot, an HOA that bans visible towers and beams, a 100 W rig, and a wish for 40m through 10m with some 80m if possible. The usual answers are an EFHW, an OCFD, a G5RV, a doublet on ladder line, or a vertical. They get compared by SWR, which is the weakest way to compare them. Here is a framework for ranking them, and I'd like to hear where people disagree.
1. SWR tells you about the match, not the radiation. A dummy load gives a perfect 1:1 and radiates nothing. What matters is how much power ends up in the far field. That is feedline loss (including mismatch loss), loss in matching components such as transformers, chokes and tuners, ground loss for verticals, and conductor and capacitor loss for small loops. Antenna height and surroundings then set the takeoff angle.
2. Feedline loss climbs with SWR. Matched loss for common coax is roughly 1 dB per 100 ft on 20m for RG-58-class cable and well under that for RG-213-class cable. Loss at high SWR is considerably worse, and it rises with frequency. A 50 ft run of decent coax with a modest SWR is fine. A long run of thin coax at 10m with a 5:1 SWR is not. Ladder line is the reverse: it stays low-loss at high SWR, which is why a doublet plus a tuner works well even when the antenna impedance is awkward.
3. Common-mode current is the hidden variable. Many "mystery" problems come from RF on the coax shield: RF in the shack, a different SWR when you move the cable, and noise pickup on receive. Put a proper choke (a 1:1 current balun, or ferrite beads or a coil of coax made with a suitable core) where the feedline leaves the antenna. An EFHW is a special case. The 49:1 or 64:1 transformer feeds a very high impedance end, and the coax shield acts as part of the counterpoise unless you manage it. A choke a short distance down the coax is the usual fix.
4. A rough ranking for a small lot with wire supports.
Doublet or non-resonant dipole on ladder line: the most flexible multiband choice. It needs a tuner and a balun or choke at the shack end, and a total length of at least about 0.3 wavelength on the lowest band. Avoid lengths that put very high impedances on a band you care about. Losses are low, and the pattern is whatever the wire length and height produce.
Inverted V: useful when you have one support. Apex height matters most. An included angle of about 90–120° works, and the resonant length is a few percent shorter than a flat-top dipole. The pattern is more omnidirectional and gain is slightly lower, but that is often a fair trade for one tall support.
EFHW: convenient, with one wire, one feed point and little ground dependence. It is resonant on harmonically related bands (a half-wave on 40m is also a half-wave on 20m, 15m and 10m). Transformer core loss and heating are the main concerns, along with the current-on-shield issue above. Quality of the transformer and choke varies a lot between designs.
OCFD: feeds at about one-third along the wire, typically through a 4:1 balun. It gives a decent match on several bands with one feedline, but the pattern is lopsided on some bands and the match depends on height and surroundings. A choke at the feed is still wise.
G5RV: a 102 ft flat-top with a ladder-line section into coax (a 51 ft half-size version exists). It was designed around 20m and needs a tuner elsewhere. It is not a bad antenna, but it is no better than a plain doublet with an appropriate balun, and the coax transition needs a choke.
Vertical: the best low-angle choice when it works, but it depends on the ground system. A ground-mounted quarter-wave over a few radials loses a lot of power in the soil. Many short radials or several elevated resonant radials make a big difference. A short loaded vertical trades bandwidth and efficiency for size.
Magnetic loop: good for tight spaces and often quieter on receive because it responds mainly to the magnetic field. The bandwidth is narrow, so you retune when you move a few tens of kHz, and efficiency depends on loop diameter, conductor and capacitor quality. Voltages across the capacitor can be very high. It is least efficient on the lowest band you ask it to cover.
5. Height. A horizontal dipole at 30 ft is about 0.44 wavelength up on 20m, which gives a good low-to-medium takeoff angle, but on 80m it is roughly 0.11 wavelength and acts as a high-angle NVIS radiator. Both uses are valid, but they are different goals. If you want DX on 40m and 80m from a small lot, a vertical or an inverted V with a high apex may serve better than a low flat-top.
Questions for the thread. If you can only put up one support, would you take an inverted V doublet on ladder line or an EFHW sloper? Does stealth (thin wire, dark color, trees) change the answer for you? And has anyone compared a compact loaded vertical against a low horizontal wire on the same bands with something more rigorous than A/B signal reports?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/10956-small-lot-hoa-80m10m-how-to-rank-efhw-ocfd-doublet-inverted-v-and-loaded-verticals-by-efficiency-rather-than-swr/Share on other sites