Choosing a handheld: Baofeng vs FT-65R vs ID-52A vs TH-D75 (and where the IC-705 fits), plus CHIRP, batteries and emergency setup
- Replies 2
- Views 38
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
Handheld choice gets confusing fast, because the cheap analog dual-banders and the digital handhelds are very different tools. This thread is for comparing what each type is good at, and for the practical side: antennas, batteries, programming and emergency use. Here is a starting framework, and corrections are welcome.
Cheap analog dual-banders (Baofeng UV-5R class, Yaesu FT-65R). These cover 2 m and 70 cm FM at roughly 5 W. They are the usual first HT for repeaters, simplex and local nets. The FT-65R costs more than the cheapest imports. In return you get a more conventional, better-documented radio from a major manufacturer, with a sturdy build and a simple interface. Baofeng-style radios are very inexpensive and widely supported in CHIRP, but they tend to have weaker receiver filtering and cruder transmit spectral purity, and the menus are clumsy. Near strong transmitters (paging, commercial sites) you may notice overload or intermod. If you only ever need a backup radio, a cheap one is fine. Just understand the tradeoff.
D-STAR: ID-52A and TH-D75. The Icom ID-52A is a dual-band handheld with D-STAR digital voice, plus analog FM, with GPS and Bluetooth features and a wide-coverage receiver. The Kenwood TH-D75 is a tri-band design (2 m, 1.25 m and 70 cm) that also does D-STAR and has built-in APRS and GPS. D-STAR only helps if there are active D-STAR repeaters or hotspots near you, so check local coverage before paying for it. Without a local network, an analog FM radio is simpler and cheaper.
The IC-705 is a different animal. It is a compact portable transceiver, not a handie-talkie. It covers HF, 6 m, 2 m and 70 cm, with D-STAR and SSB/CW/digital modes. It outputs about 5 W on its internal battery and up to 10 W on external power. It makes sense as a go-bag or portable HF/VHF station, but it is not something you clip to a belt as your everyday HT.
DMR handhelds. DMR radios from various makers work with a codeplug rather than a simple memory list. You need a DMR ID (registered through RadioID), plus talkgroups, time slots and color codes matching the repeater. The learning curve is steeper than for FM. Again, check whether your area has active DMR repeaters and who runs them, since each network has its own rules.
Programming with CHIRP. Always download the current image from the radio first and save it as a backup, then edit and upload. Use a good programming cable, since flaky cables and counterfeit USB chips are a common source of failed uploads. CHIRP supports many models but not every feature of every radio, so check its supported-radio list, especially for newer digital HTs. Repeater directory imports save time, but verify each entry against the repeater owner or local frequency coordinator.
Repeater offsets. Offsets depend on your region and band plan. As a common US example, 2 m repeaters use a 600 kHz offset (sub-band dependent for plus or minus) and 70 cm repeaters typically use 5 MHz. Many repeaters also require a CTCSS (PL) tone on transmit. A wrong tone or offset is the most frequent reason you can hear a repeater but can't key it up. Elsewhere in the world the splits differ, so use your local band plan.
Antennas and batteries. Stock rubber ducks are compromises. A better aftermarket whip, or a roll-up or telescoping antenna on a short coax, can noticeably improve range. Check the connector type (SMA male vs female) before ordering, and don't transmit without an antenna attached. For batteries, carry a spare charged pack, and consider an AA battery case or DC power option if your radio supports it. Avoid leaving Li-ion packs in a hot vehicle, and remember that high power and heavy transmit use drain a pack far faster than monitoring.
Emergency use. Program local repeaters, simplex calling frequencies (for example 146.520 MHz in the US), your local ARES or net frequencies, and weather channels where available. Keep a printed channel list with offsets and tones in case the radio resets. Only transmit where you're licensed and authorized, and never on public-safety frequencies. Practice before you need it: do a simplex test, a battery runtime test, and a net check-in.
What's your use case: repeater chats, hiking and portable, or emergency prep? And does your area lean D-STAR, DMR or just analog FM?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11003-choosing-a-handheld-baofeng-vs-ft-65r-vs-id-52a-vs-th-d75-and-where-the-ic-705-fits-plus-chirp-batteries-and-emergency-setup/Share on other sites