EME from 2 m to 10 GHz: what the link budget demands, and what JT65 and Q65 change
- Replies 2
- Views 43
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Terry 1 post
-
Mod_Chad 1 post
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
Moonbounce looks like a different hobby on each band, but the same constraints apply everywhere: a very long path, a poor reflector, and a medium that smears and rotates the signal. Round-trip path loss is very roughly 251 dB at 144 MHz, 261 dB at 432 MHz, 271 dB at 1296 MHz and close to 290 dB at 10 GHz. Those are ballpark figures, and the exact number depends on moon distance. Perigee to apogee alone is worth about 2 dB or more, so the same station can be noticeably stronger or weaker depending on the lunar cycle.
That is why digital modes mattered so much. JT65 made EME possible with signals you can't hear, using decoding that works well below the audible threshold. Q65, added to WSJT-X in the 2.4 series, targets the same kind of path with better handling of spread and fading. Both use 60-second T/R periods, so clock accuracy (NTP or GPS) is not optional. The submode letter sets the tone spacing, and it should be matched to the Doppler spread on your band. In practice, JT65A is the usual choice on 2 m, JT65B on 70 cm and 23 cm, and C or wider submodes as you go up into the microwave bands. Q65 uses the same logic with its own A to E submodes. Check the current band plan and what other stations are using before you pick one.
Hardware expectations by band, as rough guidance rather than a guarantee:
On 2 m, the antenna is usually an array of long Yagis, often four or more, with a phasing harness, low-loss hardline and a kilowatt-class amplifier where the license allows. A single large Yagi can still work the big stations in good conditions. Ground gain, galactic noise and Faraday rotation all matter more here than on the higher bands.
On 70 cm, the choices are several long Yagis or a dish of around 4 to 6 m or more. A 5 m dish has roughly 24 dBi of gain at 432 MHz, which is comparable to a small group of long Yagis. Feedline loss is expensive, so the relay and preamp belong at the antenna.
On 23 cm, dishes dominate. A 3 m dish gives roughly 30 dBi at 1296 MHz, with a beamwidth of about 5 degrees. With a good feed and a low-noise front end, modest power can make real contacts, especially against stations with larger dishes. Faraday rotation is mostly irrelevant here, so circular or well-controlled polarization works well. Libration spread is a bigger factor, which is another reason to use the wider tone-spacing submodes.
On 10 GHz, a dish of roughly 1.8 to 3 m can work. A 3 m dish has around 47 dBi of gain and a beamwidth under a degree, so pointing accuracy matters a great deal. Frequency stability becomes critical too. A 1 ppm error at 10 GHz is 10 kHz, which is far outside what you can tolerate with Doppler shift and narrow tones. GPS-disciplined references are close to standard here.
A few effects are worth separating, because they get blamed for each other:
Faraday rotation twists the polarization through the ionosphere, and it is strongest at 144 MHz. It makes signals fade slowly, over minutes, and linear polarization can lose a lot of signal when the rotation puts you in the wrong orientation. Spatial polarization offset is a geometric effect that depends on where each station sits relative to the moon. Polarization-agile arrays (switchable or rotatable) and two-polarization receive systems such as MAP65 with a Linrad-style receiver are the usual countermeasures. Libration fading comes from the moon's rocking, which creates a spread of Doppler shifts. It is a few tenths of a hertz on 2 m, a few hertz on 23 cm and much larger at 10 GHz, so it causes rapid fading and broadens the echo.
Moon tracking needs more than a rotator and a schedule. The WSJT-X Astronomical Data window shows azimuth, elevation, Doppler, spatial polarization offset (Dpol) and a degradation figure (Dgrd) that combines distance and sky noise. It is a handy way to compare dates and choose a good window. WSJT-X also has an Echo mode for measuring your own echoes and checking your system. When the moon is near the galactic plane, 2 m sky noise rises and you may hear less even with a perfect station.
Sked planning is mostly overlap math: find the time when the moon is above the horizon at both ends, with enough elevation, a tolerable Dgrd, and a polarization offset you can handle. Then agree on the band, the mode and submode, the frequency, and which station transmits in the even minutes. Coordination commonly happens on chat services such as ON4KST and in the EME newsletters and contest announcements. Ask for the other station's gain, power, polarization and pointing capabilities so that expectations are realistic.
Questions for the thread: which band is the best entry point for a station with limited space? Is Q65 now preferable to JT65 on 2 m and 70 cm, or does it depend on who is active? And what are the practical limits of a single Yagi?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11007-eme-from-2-m-to-10-ghz-what-the-link-budget-demands-and-what-jt65-and-q65-change/Share on other sites