Choosing a VHF/UHF antenna: J-pole vs 5/8 collinear vs yagi, and where installation matters more than the antenna
- Replies 2
- Views 43
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
I'd like to compare notes on the usual VHF/UHF antenna choices and on the installation details that decide how they perform. The 2 m and 70 cm bands are forgiving enough that almost anything will make some noise, so differences between setups often come from feedline, grounding and placement rather than the antenna's name.
Starting with the common vertical designs. A quarter-wave whip is about 19 in (roughly 49 cm) long on 2 m and about 6.3 in on 70 cm. It is simple, broadband and rugged, and it relies on a ground plane, which on a vehicle is the roof. A 5/8-wave whip is longer and has a lower radiation angle, so it usually gives a couple of dB more at the horizon when the ground plane is decent. It needs a matching coil or network at the base to present a sensible impedance, and it depends on that ground plane to work as designed.
The J-pole is an end-fed half-wave with a quarter-wave matching stub. The slim jim is a close relative: a folded J-pole with an open stub and a long, thin shape. Both are popular for home-built base antennas and both are vertically polarized and omnidirectional. They are often described as not needing radials, but the feedline can act as part of the antenna, because common-mode current flows on the coax shield. A choke of several turns of coax, or ferrite on the feedline near the feedpoint, can help keep the pattern predictable and reduce RF in the shack.
On gain: dBd is relative to a half-wave dipole and dBi is relative to an isotropic radiator, a difference of 2.15 dB. Be skeptical of an advertised number without the reference. On an omni vertical, extra gain comes from squashing the pattern toward the horizon, not from creating power. That is great for flat terrain and for reaching a distant repeater, but if you are in a valley or on a steep hillside a high-gain collinear can put the main lobe over the people you are trying to talk to.
For directional work, a yagi gives much more usable gain, with typical amateur designs in the 6 to 12 dBd range depending on boom length, plus front-to-back rejection that also helps cut interference from the sides and rear. Orientation matters. Mount it vertically for FM repeater work and horizontally for weak-signal SSB/CW. Cross-polarization loss can be large, and in practice 10 to 20 dB is not unusual.
On the feedline side, loss rises quickly with frequency. Rough figures: RG-58 is about 10 dB per 100 ft at 450 MHz, while LMR-400-class cable is about 2.7 dB per 100 ft. On 2 m the numbers are lower but still matter on a long run. If you have a 50 ft run to a 70 cm antenna, the coax choice can outweigh any 3 dB antenna upgrade.
Connectors: PL-259/SO-239 are common and acceptable on 2 m, but they are not constant-impedance and are not waterproof. On 70 cm and up, or on any outdoor connection, N-type is the better choice, since it has a gasket and a defined impedance. Whatever you use, seal outdoor connections with self-amalgamating tape and then a layer of vinyl tape, and form a drip loop so water does not follow the cable into the connector.
One more thing on SWR. A low reading says the transmitter sees a good match. It does not say the antenna is radiating well, because a dummy load also shows 1:1. A lossy coax run also improves the SWR you read at the radio end, since reflected power is attenuated twice on its way. If possible, check with an antenna analyzer at the antenna feedpoint.
For mobile installs, NMO mounts are a solid choice: a 3/4 in hole and a mount with good metal-to-metal contact to the body. A magnetic mount is easy to remove, but it depends on capacitive coupling to the roof, can scratch paint if dirt gets under it, and the cable running through a door seal can get pinched. Placing the mount at the roof center gives the most uniform pattern.
For satellites, FM LEO passes on 2 m/70 cm are possible with a handheld and a small handheld yagi, such as an Arrow-type, and some people use a crossed yagi with circular polarization to reduce fading. With linear antennas, polarization changes as the satellite rotates, so expect fading, and you may need to rotate the antenna to keep the signal up.
Questions for the thread: what are you running now, and what is its biggest limitation: coverage, noise, TX range, or mounting? If you were choosing between a collinear and a small yagi for repeater access, how would you decide? And do you use a choke on J-pole/slim jim feedlines?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11028-choosing-a-vhfuhf-antenna-j-pole-vs-58-collinear-vs-yagi-and-where-installation-matters-more-than-the-antenna/Share on other sites