Making SET and Field Day count: practicing message handling, net discipline and served-agency work before the real event
- Replies 2
- Views 56
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
Most of us agree that Field Day and the Simulated Emergency Test (SET) are good practice. In many groups, though, they end up as a contest weekend and a quick drill that nobody reviews. I'd like to compare notes on how to turn them into training that carries over to a hurricane, wildfire, flood, earthquake, tornado outbreak or extended grid failure.
Here are a few starting points. Please add your own.
1. Treat message handling as the main skill. Making contacts is not the goal of emergency communication. Getting a message from the originator to the addressee, accurately and with accountability, is. Field Day is a good place to practice because there is already a message-origination bonus and plenty of idle operators. Do you also practice writing a message so the text is short and unambiguous? Do you practice checking the word count, reading it back, and logging who passed it to whom? A radiogram has a number, precedence, handling instructions, station of origin, check, place of origin, time and date filed, addressee, text and signature. Agencies may instead hand you an ICS-213 General Message form. Operators should be comfortable moving between the two without dropping information.
2. Plain language over shorthand. Served agencies generally want plain language, not ham jargon or police-style codes. Q-signals are fine between operators on CW, but on voice nets "net control, I have a hospital with no generator fuel and fourteen patients on oxygen" is far better than anything clever. Is your net script written to encourage that?
3. Net scripts that survive stress. A good script usually has a short preamble (purpose, frequency, who is in control), a call for emergency or priority traffic first, check-ins by category (for example, stations at shelters, at the EOC, mobile, and general), then a traffic list and a clear closing. Tactical call signs such as "Shelter North" or "County EOC" help when operators rotate through shifts, as long as legal station identification is still done with the FCC call sign at the required intervals. Does your script cover what to do when net control drops off, the repeater fails, or the primary frequency is unusable? Does it say who takes over, and where the group moves next?
4. Scenario variety. Each hazard stresses a different part of the system:
Hurricanes are long-duration events with shelter staffing, fuel logistics and operator fatigue, plus a lot of welfare traffic after landfall. Wildfires bring evacuation, smoke, road closures and the loss of mountaintop repeater sites to fire or power failure. Floods cut off access routes and can isolate whole communities. Earthquakes call for rapid damage assessment and for working without the infrastructure you normally rely on. Tornadoes give very little warning and rely on SKYWARN-style spotter reporting, followed by a different set of needs after the storm. Grid failures test battery capacity, generator discipline, repeater backup power and cellular congestion. Which of these does your local SET scenario rarely cover?
5. After-action reports that change something. A useful after-action report (AAR) is short and specific. It lists what the exercise set out to test, what worked, what didn't, why, and a corrective action with a named owner and a due date. If every AAR ends with "improve training," nothing will change. If it says "re-test the 2-meter simplex fallback between the shelter and the EOC before the next quarterly drill," something will.
6. Working with served agencies. Relationships built before an activation make a big difference. Do your agency contacts know what you can and cannot do? Have they seen your credentials or training records? Have they been invited to observe a drill and give feedback on the message forms and the process? Often the most valuable part of an exercise is hearing the served agency say "we wouldn't have asked for it that way."
What has your group changed after an exercise, and what do you think most drills still get wrong?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11072-making-set-and-field-day-count-practicing-message-handling-net-discipline-and-served-agency-work-before-the-real-event/Share on other sites