Starting EME: what really limits 2 m, 70 cm, 23 cm and 10 GHz moonbounce stations?
- Replies 2
- Views 43
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Terry 1 post
-
Mod_Dan 1 post
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
I want to compare what each band demands for a first EME station: arrays versus dishes, preamp placement, polarization, and how much tracking accuracy you need. I'll start with a framework, and please correct anything that's off.
The round-trip path loss is very large on every band. A commonly quoted figure is roughly 250 dB at 144 MHz, rising about 9.5 dB each time frequency triples (about 261 dB at 432 MHz and about 271 dB at 1296 MHz). Antenna gain also rises with frequency for a given physical size, which is why a 3 m dish is a small antenna on 2 m but a serious one on 23 cm. Moon distance matters too. Between perigee and apogee the path loss changes by a couple of dB, so a marginal sked usually works better near perigee.
Each band has a different main problem:
On 2 m, the difficulties are sky noise, Faraday rotation and the size of the array. Galactic background noise is high, so the moon's position against the sky matters a lot. Polarization fading from the ionosphere is strongest here.
On 70 cm, Faraday rotation is much slower, since it scales roughly with 1/f². Array size and feed-line loss become more important.
On 23 cm, Faraday rotation is generally negligible. The main work is a decent dish, a low-loss feed system, and pointing within a fraction of the beamwidth. A 3 m dish at 1296 MHz has a beamwidth of roughly 5 degrees, using the rule of thumb 70λ/D.
On 10 GHz and other microwave bands, the beam is under a degree for a few-metre dish, so pointing and mechanical stiffness dominate. Libration spreading is also much larger, which reduces the peak signal in narrowband modes.
On software, JT65 has been the traditional EME mode, with the B, C and higher sub-modes chosen to suit the band's Doppler spread. Q65 is now an alternative, with sub-modes designed for different spreads and the ability to average over several periods. WSJT-X's Astronomical Data window shows azimuth, elevation, Doppler, spread, sky-noise degradation and polarization offset, which helps with both planning and operating.
My questions for the group:
1) Is a small 2 m array of a few long Yagis a realistic start, or should a newcomer go straight to 23 cm with a dish?
2) How much does a mast-mounted preamp with a low-loss relay change things compared with a shack-end preamp?
3) How do you plan skeds around moon declination, sky temperature and mutual window time?
4) What is the minimum I need to be able to hear my own echoes, and is that even a sensible test on every band?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11091-starting-eme-what-really-limits-2-m-70-cm-23-cm-and-10-ghz-moonbounce-stations/Share on other sites