Choosing a VHF/UHF antenna: J-pole vs slim jim vs collinear vs yagi, and what SWR doesn't tell you
- Replies 2
- Views 35
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
There are a lot of 2 m / 70 cm antenna choices, and the marketing numbers rarely help. Let's try to sort out what actually changes your results: pattern, polarization, feedline loss and installation. Gain figures come last.
Omni vertical options. A J-pole is an end-fed half-wave with a quarter-wave matching stub. A slim jim is a close relative with the stub folded into a slim, tall shape. Both are cheap and usually give roughly unity gain or a bit better, with a fairly low takeoff angle. Because they're end-fed, they don't depend on a ground plane the way a quarter-wave whip does. That also means the coax shield can become part of the antenna. Without a choke (a few turns of coax or a ferrite choke near the feedpoint) and some distance from a metal mast, common-mode current can distort the pattern and shift the apparent SWR.
Collinears. Stacking phased half-wave or 5/8-wave sections squeezes the pattern in the vertical plane, so more energy goes toward the horizon. That helps on flat terrain. It can hurt if you're in a valley or below a repeater on a hill, where you may need some upward radiation. Be skeptical of dBd versus dBi on the packaging. A 3 dB difference on paper is just the 2.15 dB reference difference plus whatever optimism the maker added.
Yagis. A yagi trades coverage for gain. As a rough rule, doubling boom length in a well-designed yagi adds about 3 dB. Beamwidth narrows, so rotating or aiming becomes part of the job. For FM repeater work, mount it vertically polarized to match everyone else. For SSB/CW weak-signal work on 2 m and 70 cm, horizontal is the usual convention.
Polarization. Cross-polarized paths can lose a lot of signal, in theory 20 dB or more. Real paths with reflections are usually less severe but still noticeable. A tilted handheld antenna and a vertical repeater antenna also don't match perfectly.
Feedline and connectors. Coax loss rises quickly with frequency. Typical figures are around 4–5 dB per 100 ft for RG-58 on 2 m and noticeably worse on 70 cm. Low-loss 400-class cable is around 1.5 dB per 100 ft at 2 m and under 3 dB at 70 cm. Check the datasheet for your cable, because numbers vary by manufacturer. PL-259 (UHF) connectors are fine for HF and acceptable on 2 m, but they aren't constant-impedance. For 70 cm and anything outdoors, N-type is a better choice, and its gasket helps keep water out.
SWR. A 1.5:1 SWR reflects about 4% of the power at the mismatch, and 2:1 reflects about 11%. Those numbers aren't the real issue. SWR measured at the radio through a long run of lossy coax will look better than it is at the antenna, because the loss attenuates the reflected wave. A low reading also doesn't prove the antenna radiates well, since a dummy load has a perfect SWR.
So what are you trying to cover: a local repeater, simplex across town, or satellite passes? And what mounting constraints (roof, mast, vehicle) do you have? Those usually decide the antenna more than the gain rating does.
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11098-choosing-a-vhfuhf-antenna-j-pole-vs-slim-jim-vs-collinear-vs-yagi-and-what-swr-doesnt-tell-you/Share on other sites