Choosing between J-pole, slim jim, collinear and 5/8 mobile antennas: what matters more, gain or feedline and installation?
- Replies 2
- Views 56
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Mod_Chad 1 post
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
Antenna choices on 2 m and 70 cm often start with gain figures on a box. In practice the result depends on a few things working together: the antenna type, how well it is isolated from the feedline, the ground plane (if it needs one), the coax loss, and the height and clearance of the install. This thread is for comparing common designs and sorting out which claims hold up.
Quarter-wave whip vs 5/8 wave. A quarter-wave whip is about 19 in (48 cm) on 2 m and about 6.5 in (16.5 cm) on 70 cm. It is simple, rugged and presents a feed impedance close to 50 ohms over a decent ground plane. A 5/8 wave is taller, roughly 50 in on 2 m, and uses a matching coil at the base. It has more gain in theory (around 3 dB over a quarter-wave), with a lower radiation angle. That advantage depends on a good ground plane. A 5/8 on a small or off-center ground can lose most of its benefit and may show an erratic pattern. On a vehicle, a roof-center NMO mount usually behaves best, a trunk-lip mount less so, and a mag mount is somewhere in between depending on contact with the body and the size of the metal around it.
NMO vs mag mount. NMO needs a roughly 3/4 in hole but gives a solid, repeatable connection and a ground that does not depend on capacitive coupling. A mag mount is quick and removable, but it is easy to get a poor ground (paint, dirt, a mount sitting on a rough surface), and the thin coax commonly supplied is lossy at 70 cm. Both need coax routed so it is not pinched in a door seal.
J-pole and slim jim. Both are end-fed half-wave radiators with a quarter-wave matching section. They do not need a ground plane, which is why they are popular as base antennas. Their gain is close to a half-wave dipole, so be skeptical of figures like 6 dB. The weak point is common-mode current: without a choke or decoupling, the coax outer can become part of the radiator. That distorts the pattern and can change the SWR depending on how the cable is moved. A slim jim is a folded variant in a long, thin form. A well-built one often has a good low-angle pattern, but the gain is not dramatically higher than a J-pole.
Collinears and yagis. A collinear stacks phased elements to squeeze the elevation pattern and add gain in all horizontal directions. Higher gain means a narrower vertical beamwidth, which can be a disadvantage in hilly terrain or when the antenna is mounted very high near the target stations. Mounting matters too: a vertical collinear attached directly to a metal mast can distort the pattern, so use an offset arm or follow the manufacturer's spacing. A yagi gives directional gain, typically in the 6 to 12 dBi range depending on boom length. It is used for repeaters at the edge of coverage, weak-signal work and satellite work. Polarization matters here. FM voice on 2 m and 70 cm is conventionally vertical, while SSB/CW weak-signal work is conventionally horizontal. Cross-polarized stations can lose a lot of signal.
Coax, connectors and SWR. Coax loss rises quickly at 70 cm. Approximate figures: RG-58 is around 10 dB/100 ft at 450 MHz, while LMR-400-type cable is under 3 dB/100 ft. Check the datasheet for the exact cable. For outdoor runs, N-type connectors are a better choice than PL-259/SO-239 (the 'UHF' connector). N-type is constant-impedance, has a gasket, and holds up better at UHF. PL-259s are fine for many short VHF runs, but they are not impedance-controlled and are easy to water-soak. Weatherproof any outdoor connection properly with self-amalgamating tape and a protective outer wrap.
One common SWR trap: measuring at the radio end of a lossy cable makes the antenna look better than it is, because the reflected power is also attenuated by the cable. A low SWR does not prove the antenna is radiating efficiently. A dummy-load-like result can look excellent on the meter. Measuring at the antenna end with an analyzer, or at least knowing the cable loss, gives a better picture.
Repeater and satellite antennas. A repeater site typically uses a vertically polarized omnidirectional collinear, or a directional antenna when coverage needs to be shaped. It also needs good isolation between transmit and receive (duplexer or sufficient separation), low-loss feedline and grounding/surge protection. For LEO satellites, the common choices are a handheld or small directional yagi, such as an Arrow-style antenna, or a pair of crossed yagis with circular polarization on a az/el rotator. Circular polarization helps with spin and orientation changes of the satellite. A simple vertical will work on some passes but with deep fading and a poor low-angle gain trade-off.
Where would you spend the first budget increment: better coax, a better mount, or a higher-gain antenna? And what installation mistakes show up most often?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11105-choosing-between-j-pole-slim-jim-collinear-and-58-mobile-antennas-what-matters-more-gain-or-feedline-and-installation/Share on other sites