Small lot, one tall support, HOA rules: EFHW vs. doublet vs. inverted V vs. vertical for 80-10 m
- Replies 2
- Views 28
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
Here is a scenario that comes up constantly. Take a lot with maybe 50 feet of usable width, one 30-35 ft support (a tree, a mast or a fiberglass pole), and a covenant that bans visible towers and beams. The goal is 40 m through 10 m with a decent shot at DX, and 80 m if it can be had. The question is which compromise does the least damage.
Before comparing wire shapes, two points are worth agreeing on. First, SWR tells you how well the load matches the transmitter. It says almost nothing about how much power ends up radiated. A dummy load has a perfect SWR and a terrible pattern. Second, on a small lot the real losses tend to hide in three places: the ground system (for verticals), the matching device or transformer, and common-mode current on the feedline. SWR on the shack side of the coax shows none of these.
The candidates, with my understanding of the trade-offs:
End-fed half-wave (EFHW). A 40 m version is roughly 64-67 ft of wire fed through a 49:1 or 64:1 transformer. It is resonant on 40, 20, 15 and 10 m as harmonics, which is why it is so easy to deploy with no tuner. Feedpoint impedance is in the low thousands of ohms, so transformer core material, turns and power rating decide how much power is lost as heat. There is no true balanced feed either, so the coax shield becomes part of the antenna unless you add a good common-mode choke near the transformer.
Doublet or G5RV-style. A center-fed wire with ladder line or window line, run into a tuner with a balanced output or a 4:1 balun. The line loss stays low even at high SWR, which is the main appeal. The tradeoffs are a tuner at the station and the need to route open-wire line away from metal, gutters and the house wiring. A G5RV is a doublet with a particular length (about 102 ft) and a short ladder-line section, and it is not magic on every band.
Inverted V. A dipole with the apex on the support and the ends sloping down. It is easy to hide, since the ends can run along a fence line. Resonant length is a little shorter than a flat-top and bandwidth is slightly wider. The pattern is fairly omnidirectional, and radiation depends heavily on apex height in wavelengths. At 30-35 ft, 40 m is around a quarter wave, which gives a lot of high-angle energy that is good for regional work but not ideal for DX.
Vertical. A vertical has a naturally low takeoff angle, but the efficiency depends on the radial field. A ground-mounted quarter-wave with only a few radials can lose a large share of power in ground resistance. Elevated resonant radials (several of them, cut for the band) tend to be more efficient per radial than buried ones, but they need to be placed where people will not trip on them.
Where would you start, and why? I am especially curious how people weigh a no-tuner multiband wire against a tuned doublet when the antenna is going to sit low and be hidden anyway.
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11201-small-lot-one-tall-support-hoa-rules-efhw-vs-doublet-vs-inverted-v-vs-vertical-for-80-10-m/Share on other sites