EME by band: what each step up from 2 m to 10 GHz demands in antennas, receive sensitivity, polarization and scheduling
- Replies 2
- Views 29
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
This thread is for comparing what moonbounce asks of a station on each band, and where the hard limits are. Some figures below are rounded, and individual stations vary a lot, so correct anything that looks off.
Path loss is the starting point. Round-trip loss to the Moon is roughly 252 dB on 144 MHz, 261 dB on 432, 271 dB on 1296 and close to 289 dB on 10 GHz. The Moon's distance also changes. Perigee to apogee is about a 2 dB swing in round-trip loss, so the same station sounds noticeably better near perigee. Your own echo returns about 2.5 seconds after you transmit, which is a quick check on whether the station is working at all.
2 m: This is the most forgiving band for receive noise, because galactic noise limits you, but it is the hardest for polarization. A typical serious array is four or more long-boom Yagis phased together, often with a legal-limit or near-legal amplifier. Feedline loss matters more than people expect, since every 0.1 dB lost in the line is lost on both transmit and receive. A mast-mounted preamp with relays that stay low-loss helps, but sequencing the relay and preamp protection correctly is non-negotiable. Smaller stations can sometimes complete with large ones using JT65 or Q65, but they usually cannot hear their own echoes, so they depend on the big station's ears.
70 cm: Gain is easier per square metre of antenna, but you need more of it. Arrays of several Yagis are common. Sky temperature starts to matter, and low-noise preamps and short, low-loss lines pay off. Faraday rotation is still present but slower and less severe than on 2 m.
23 cm: Dishes become attractive. A dish of about 3 m with a good feed and a modest amplifier is a common entry point, and beamwidth is still around 5 degrees (roughly 70 × wavelength / diameter), so tracking is not demanding. Faraday rotation is small enough that most stations use circular polarization. Reflection reverses circular sense, so agree the convention with your partner and expect your own echoes to come back in the opposite sense from what you send.
10 GHz and up: The same 3 m dish now has a beam well under a degree, close to the Moon's own 0.5 degree diameter, so pointing accuracy, backlash and sun-tracking checks all matter. Doppler shift is in the tens of kHz and libration spread is much wider, so frequency stability, ideally a GPS-disciplined reference, is essential. Wide-tone digital submodes exist for these conditions.
Modes: JT65 has long been the weak-signal workhorse, with submodes (A, B, C) chosen by Doppler spread. Q65 in WSJT-X is the newer option, with 60-second periods and tone-spacing submodes that suit the wider spread at higher bands. The usual guidance is the narrowest submode on 2 m, wider ones on 70 cm and 23 cm, and the widest on microwaves, but check the current WSJT-X documentation and local practice before a sked.
For discussion: where do you think the best marginal gain is for a station moving up a band, more gain, lower noise, or better tracking? And which polarization approach is the most practical for a fixed-feed 2 m array?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11291-eme-by-band-what-each-step-up-from-2-m-to-10-ghz-demands-in-antennas-receive-sensitivity-polarization-and-scheduling/Share on other sites