HF shack planning: radio choice matters less than the power, grounding and RF-environment decisions around it
- Replies 2
- Views 29
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Mod_Chad 1 post
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
Radio comparisons tend to dominate shack discussions: IC-7300 vs FT-991A, TS-590SG vs a newer TS-890S, K3S vs a KX3 on a desk. The radio is only one link in the chain, though. Here is a framework for thinking about the rest of the shack, with the radios as examples. Corrections are welcome.
Start with what the radio actually does. The IC-7300 is a single-receiver direct-sampling SDR at 100 W with a built-in tuner. The IC-7610 keeps that architecture but adds a second receiver path with its own ADC, which helps for SO2R-style monitoring or split-pileup work. The FT-991A is a superhet that also covers VHF/UHF, so it suits someone who wants one box for everything. The FTDX10 is a hybrid design with a stronger HF focus. The TS-590SG and TS-890S sit on the Kenwood superhet side, with the 890 being the more serious receiver. The K3S is a modular 100 W rig with a long reputation for receiver performance, while the KX3 is a 10 W-class portable that also works on a desk. The G90 is a 20 W SDR with an internal ATU, aimed at portable and low-power use. These differ in receiver dynamic range, filtering, display and ergonomics, but all of them are fine rigs if the rest of the station is sound.
Power supply. A 100 W HF rig on SSB or CW draws roughly 20 A at 13.8 V at full output, and more on digital modes at high duty cycle. A 30 A supply is a sensible minimum for a 100 W rig, and the supply should be rated for continuous duty. Use adequately heavy DC cable, fuse near the source, and keep the run short so voltage drop under load doesn't pull the rig below spec. If a switching supply puts birdies or a raised noise floor on the bands, try ferrites on the DC leads, move the supply away from the receive antenna's feedline, or compare it against a different supply before blaming the radio.
Tuners. An antenna tuner matches the load the transmitter sees. It does not make the antenna more efficient or fix feedline loss. An internal ATU in a G90 or IC-7300 is convenient for modest mismatches, but with a very high SWR or lossy coax the loss is in the line, not at the radio's output. A remote tuner at the feedpoint behaves differently from a tuner at the shack end, because it reduces the SWR on the feedline itself.
Amplifiers. Check how much drive the amp wants. Many 1 kW-class amps need around 50-100 W depending on the model, so a 100 W rig is typically run at reduced power. Connect the amp's keying line and ALC (if available) so a mismatch or an overdriven stage doesn't splatter. Run the amp into a good load, and use the radio's band data or relay-keying features to prevent hot switching.
Band-pass filters. These matter when two transmitters operate close together, such as a multi-op or SO2R station, or when a nearby strong signal overloads the receiver front end. For a single-radio shack with a single antenna they usually aren't necessary, and they add insertion loss and another box in the chain.
Grounding and bonding. This is the part people most often get wrong. Safety grounding (via the mains ground and equipment chassis), lightning protection (an entrance panel at the point where lines enter, bonded to the building's grounding system) and RF grounding are three different things. Bond the station equipment together so everything sits at the same potential, and bond the antenna system grounds to the house service ground rather than leaving separate ground rods floating. Follow your local electrical code and consult a qualified electrician for anything on the mains side. Common-mode chokes on coax and other cables often fix RF-in-the-shack problems better than a longer ground wire does.
Layout. Keep the receive-sensitive and noisy stuff (supplies, computers, USB hubs, LED lighting) physically separate, keep coax and power cables from running in parallel bundles, and plan the cable paths before you plug things in.
Where would you put your first dollar of upgrade money: a better radio, a better antenna, or the noise and safety side of the station?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11322-hf-shack-planning-radio-choice-matters-less-than-the-power-grounding-and-rf-environment-decisions-around-it/Share on other sites