Picking a VHF/UHF base or mobile antenna: where J-poles, collinears, 5/8 wave whips and yagis each make sense (and why SWR alone misleads)
- Replies 2
- Views 29
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Terry 1 post
-
Mod_Chad 1 post
I want to compare antenna choices for 2 m and 70 cm without relying on catalog gain figures. Gain is relative to something (dBd to a dipole, dBi to an isotropic radiator, and the two differ by 2.15 dB). It is also paid for by squeezing the pattern in elevation, so a higher number does not automatically mean a better antenna for your location.
Quarter-wave whip. At 146 MHz a quarter wave is roughly 19 inches, and at 446 MHz roughly 6.5 inches. It is the simple reference design: low-angle pattern, broad coverage, and about unity gain at best. It needs a ground plane, such as a vehicle roof or a set of radials. On a small or off-center ground the pattern tilts and the match shifts. It is mechanically rugged and forgiving, which counts for a lot on a vehicle.
5/8 wave. A 5/8 wave vertical, or the common 5/8 over 5/8 or 1/2 over 5/8 variants, flattens the pattern a little and is often quoted at about 3 dB over a quarter wave in the ideal case. It needs a matching coil or network at the base, and it depends on a decent ground plane. A 5/8 wave on a small ground, such as a mag mount on a small metal patch, can disappoint. The match may look acceptable while the pattern points upward and the radiation efficiency suffers.
J-pole and Slim Jim. A J-pole is an end-fed half-wave radiator with a quarter-wave matching stub, so it needs no radials in principle. In practice the feedline can become part of the antenna, so a choke (ferrite beads or a few coiled turns of coax) at the feedpoint often helps. Expect about dipole-like performance. A Slim Jim is a close relative with a folded, differently arranged radiator. Its pattern can be a little flatter, but claimed gain figures should be taken with caution unless they come from measurements. Both are cheap to build and handle well outdoors if you keep the feedpoint dry.
Collinears. Stacking phased half-wave elements narrows the vertical beamwidth and raises gain, from a few dB to much more for long designs. For repeater work on flat terrain that is useful. In hilly terrain, or if the mast isn't plumb, the main lobe can overshoot the stations you want to reach. A very high-gain vertical is also unforgiving of mast lean and of nearby metal.
Yagis. A yagi gives directivity, front-to-back rejection and the ability to ignore noise or interference from other directions. Polarization has to match: FM repeater and simplex use is mostly vertical, while weak-signal SSB/CW work on 2 m and 70 cm is conventionally horizontal. Cross-polarized links can lose a lot of signal, often 10 to 20 dB or more depending on the path.
Mag mount versus NMO. A mag mount is quick, but the coax has to be routed (often under a door seal or hatch), and the ground coupling can be capacitive through the paint and the magnet's base. A permanent NMO mount in the roof center gives the most predictable pattern and the best bond, at the cost of a 3/4 inch hole. The whip itself on an NMO base is usually a quarter wave, 5/8 wave, or a collinear-type design, and it can be changed without touching the cable.
Coax and connectors. Feedline loss rises with frequency, so a run that works at 146 MHz may be costly at 446 MHz. As a rough guide (check datasheets): RG-58 might lose about 5 dB per 100 ft at 150 MHz and about double that at 450 MHz, while LMR-400 or equivalent is far lower, in the 1.5 to 3 dB per 100 ft range across those bands. The PL-259 (UHF connector) is fine for general VHF use, but it is not a constant-impedance design, it isn't inherently weatherproof, and it's a poor choice at 70 cm and above for outdoor installs. An N-type is constant 50 ohm, sealed with a gasket, and holds up much better outdoors and at higher frequencies.
SWR. A low SWR tells you the antenna system presents close to 50 ohms at the measurement point. It does not tell you the antenna is radiating well. A dummy load gives 1:1, and a long run of lossy coax will make a bad antenna read better at the radio end. If you can, check SWR at the antenna end or with a known-good short jumper. Check the SWR across the whole band you use and not just a single frequency, because a design with a narrow bandwidth can look fine at 146.52 and poorly at 147.
Repeater and satellite use. For repeater work, a vertical, omnidirectional antenna with a modest gain is typical, with enough vertical separation or filtering to keep transmit and receive paths from desensing each other. For FM satellites, you're working a moving target with a linearly polarized handheld yagi. Fading comes from the rotation of the satellite and polarization mismatch. Circular polarization, or a rotator-mounted crossed yagi, helps. Which of these tradeoffs matters most to you: the pattern, the install effort, or the cost of a good feedline?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11355-picking-a-vhfuhf-base-or-mobile-antenna-where-j-poles-collinears-58-wave-whips-and-yagis-each-make-sense-and-why-swr-alone-misleads/Share on other sites