Building a field kit that actually works: EFHW vs linked dipole, LiFePO4 power, and what to do about weather
- Replies 2
- Views 21
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
Thought I'd start a general thread on how people structure a portable kit for POTA, SOTA and Field Day style outings. Gear lists are fun, but the tradeoffs between pieces matter more than any single item. Here's how I'd frame the main decisions, and I'd like to hear where others land.
Antenna: EFHW or linked dipole? An end-fed half-wave (EFHW) with a 49:1 style transformer is popular because it's one wire, one feedpoint at the bottom, and it's resonant on the fundamental and its harmonics. A 40 m version is roughly 20 m (about 66 ft) of radiator and also works on 20, 15 and 10 m. The catches are that the feedpoint is high impedance, so it needs a decent transformer that can handle the power and a bit of counterpoise (often the coax shield, which is why a common-mode choke is worth having). A linked dipole is centre-fed, usually behaves predictably, and gives you a good match on each band you've set up links for. The price is changing links in the field and carrying more wire and a bigger footprint. If you're moving fast on a summit, the EFHW usually wins on speed. If you're parked at a picnic table for a couple of hours and want to hop between bands, the linked dipole's predictability appeals.
Support: telescopic poles. A 10 m (33 ft) fibreglass pole is a common sweet spot. Heavier than a 6 or 7 m pole, but it gets a 40 m dipole's centre up where it can work. Whatever you use, guy it. A few lengths of cord at the upper joints, plus a stake or a clamp at the base, will save you from a pole that slowly collapses on air. Collapsed sections that slip are a common failure, so a strip of tape or hose clamps on joints keeps heights consistent. Also check your site: an inverted-V on a pole is easy, but a sloper off a tree or railing might be all you can do in some parks.
Power: LiFePO4 and solar. A 4-cell LiFePO4 pack is about 12.8 V nominal, charges to roughly 14.4-14.6 V, and holds a fairly flat voltage through most of its capacity, which suits most 12 V rigs. Check your radio's input range anyway, since the full-charge voltage is a bit higher than a typical lead-acid float. Fuse close to the battery, use polarity-keyed connectors (Powerpoles are the usual ham choice), and don't charge lithium-iron cells below freezing unless the pack has low-temperature charge protection. For solar, the charge controller needs to be appropriate for the chemistry. Don't just wire a panel straight to a battery. Panel output also drops in clouds and shade, so treat it as a top-up, not a guarantee.
Logging. Paper is still the most reliable backup because it doesn't die in the cold. If you log digitally, use UTC, and for POTA keep the park reference handy so your ADIF can carry it. Remember that a POTA activation needs 10 QSOs within a single UTC day, and a SOTA activation needs at least 4 contacts to count for points from within the activation zone. Know the rules for your specific program before you go.
Weather and safety. A mast is a lightning rod. If you can hear thunder, it's time to take the antenna down and get out of the exposed spot. A common rule of thumb is to wait about 30 minutes after the last thunder before resuming. Also tell someone your plan and expected return, carry layers and water, and be aware of whether you have cell coverage. For summits, the radio is the least important item in the pack.
So: what's your default antenna and pole combination, and what's one thing you'd change about your kit if you had to cut weight in half? Also curious how people handle logging in the rain or cold.
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11366-building-a-field-kit-that-actually-works-efhw-vs-linked-dipole-lifepo4-power-and-what-to-do-about-weather/Share on other sites