VHF/UHF antenna choices: gain vs. pattern, J-poles and collinears, mag mounts vs. NMO, and why coax and connectors matter
- Replies 2
- Views 25
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
This is a discussion starter for anyone choosing or troubleshooting a 2 m / 70 cm antenna. Most problems in this area come from a few trade-offs that get blurred in marketing: gain versus pattern, SWR versus real efficiency, and feedline loss versus antenna choice. Here are my starting points. Please correct or add to them.
Quarter-wave, 5/8 wave and what 'gain' means. A quarter-wave whip is about 19 inches on 2 m and about 6.5 inches on 70 cm. It is simple and broadband, and it needs a decent ground plane, which on a vehicle means the roof. A 5/8-wave whip is longer and uses a loading coil or matching network at the base. Its main benefit is a lower takeoff angle, which concentrates energy toward the horizon. In a good installation that usually works out to a couple of dB over a quarter-wave. The catch is that the gain is not magic. It comes from squashing the vertical pattern, so on steep terrain or very close to a repeater on a hill, a lower-gain antenna can sometimes do as well. Gain figures also come in dBi or dBd, and the two differ by 2.15 dB, so check which one a spec sheet uses before comparing antennas.
J-pole and slim jim. A J-pole is an end-fed half-wave radiator with a quarter-wave matching stub. Because the radiator is a half-wave rather than a quarter-wave over a ground plane, it does not depend on a ground plane or radials. That makes it popular for home-built and portable use. A slim jim is a related design, with a folded half-wave radiator that also gives a low-angle pattern. Both are end-fed, so the coax shield can carry common-mode current and become part of the antenna. If you see SWR or pattern changing when you move the cable, that is a likely cause. A choke (ferrite beads or a few turns of coax) near the feedpoint often helps. The ready-made versions usually perform better than rough builds mainly because their dimensions are controlled.
Collinears and yagis. A collinear stacks several in-phase radiating sections in a vertical line. Each doubling of the number of sections ideally adds about 3 dB, at the cost of a narrower vertical beam. That suits a repeater or base station that needs omnidirectional coverage over flat ground, but it can cause nulls in near-field coverage if the beam is too narrow, or if the mast tilts. A yagi concentrates gain in one direction. It is the usual choice for reaching a distant repeater, for simplex DX, or for weak-signal work. Remember polarization: FM voice on VHF/UHF is conventionally vertical, while SSB and CW weak-signal work is conventionally horizontal. Cross-polarized signals can lose a large amount, often 20 dB or more in practice, though reflections reduce this in cluttered environments.
Mobile mounting: mag mount vs. NMO. An NMO mount is a drilled-hole mount, usually 3/4 inch, with the base clamped to the metal body. It gives a solid electrical ground and mechanical stability at highway speeds. A mag mount is quick and does not require drilling, but it couples to the vehicle body partly capacitively through the paint and the pad. It works best near the center of a metal roof. Keep the magnet and the surface clean, since grit scratches paint and can reduce coupling. If the whip is cut or tuned for a quarter-wave, check SWR in the actual mounting position, because the roof shape and mount location affect the match. Also keep the coax from being pinched in a door seal.
SWR is not efficiency. SWR only tells you how well the load matches the feedline at the point of measurement. A low SWR can hide a badly lossy cable, and a poor antenna can look fine on a meter if the coax absorbs the reflected power. Measure at the antenna end if you can. A high reading with a short, quality cable indicates real trouble, such as a bad connector, a damaged element, or incorrect length. Remember too that SWR is frequency-dependent. Check it at the band edges and at the frequencies you actually use.
Coax and connectors. Loss rises with frequency, so a run that is acceptable on 2 m can be disappointing on 70 cm. Small-diameter cables like RG-58 lose a lot over a long run at UHF, while larger low-loss cable such as LMR-400 or similar has much less. Check the manufacturer's datasheet for attenuation at your frequency and length rather than guessing. For connectors, the PL-259 (UHF connector) is common and fine for HF and much VHF use, but it is not a constant-impedance connector, and it is a weaker choice at higher UHF and when weatherproofing matters. N-type is a constant-impedance 50-ohm connector, with a better weather seal, and it is the typical choice for UHF and for permanent outdoor runs. Whatever you use, tape or seal outdoor connections properly. Water ingress is one of the most common reasons for a gradual SWR rise.
Repeater and satellite use. For a repeater, the antenna's pattern and height matter more than peak gain, and a repeater with a duplexer needs a single antenna with good isolation and a clean match. Many users reach a repeater with a simple vertical, and a small yagi helps if the path is marginal. For satellites, the geometry changes. A low-orbit satellite moves across the sky, so a fixed omnidirectional antenna covers the whole pass but at low gain. A hand-held directional yagi gives more signal but needs to be pointed and rotated. Satellite signals often fade because of polarization changes as the spacecraft rotates. Circularly polarized antennas, or crossed yagis with a suitable phasing harness, reduce this. Also note that FM satellites commonly use different bands for uplink and downlink, so you need to account for Doppler shift and for receiving while you transmit.
What would you prioritize in a first permanent VHF/UHF installation: a high-gain collinear on a mast, a simpler J-pole, or a small yagi with a rotator? And what coax would you buy for a 50-foot run?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11391-vhfuhf-antenna-choices-gain-vs-pattern-j-poles-and-collinears-mag-mounts-vs-nmo-and-why-coax-and-connectors-matter/Share on other sites