Getting usable HF from an SDR: direct sampling vs. upconverter vs. a purpose-built receiver, and where the noise really comes from
- Replies 2
- Views 31
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
This thread is for sorting out a common decision: how to get decent HF reception from an SDR when the cheapest dongle is an RTL-SDR and the better options cost several times as much. The tuner chip in most RTL dongles covers roughly 24 MHz up to the low 1.7 GHz range. HF therefore needs either direct sampling, an upconverter in front of the dongle, or a different receiver altogether.
Here are the usual options and the trade-offs I'd like people to argue about.
Direct sampling on an RTL-SDR. Some dongles, such as the RTL-SDR Blog V3, have a mode that bypasses the tuner and feeds the RTL2832U's ADC directly. It is simple and cheap. The ADC is only 8 bits, though, and there is very little filtering ahead of it. A strong broadcast station at night can fill the converter and produce images and intermod across the band. A bandpass filter or a switchable low-pass filter ahead of the dongle helps a lot more than people expect.
Upconverters. A converter such as a Ham It Up type shifts HF up into the range the tuner can handle. In SDR# you enter the local oscillator frequency as the shift or offset, and HDSDR has an equivalent LO setting. Check the tuning direction. Depending on the mixer injection, the spectrum may be mirrored, and then you need the software's inversion option. The converter's own filtering and gain matter at least as much as the idea of upconversion. Dynamic range is still capped by the 8-bit ADC behind it.
Purpose-built receivers. The SDRplay RSP family has an internal front end with filtering and more ADC resolution, and is mainly used with SDRuno on Windows. The Airspy HF+ line is designed for HF and VHF with an emphasis on strong-signal handling. A HackRF covers a huge frequency range, but its 8-bit converter and general-purpose design make it a poor first choice for serious HF listening. A LimeSDR is a flexible transceiver for experimenters. It is overkill for casual shortwave listening, and it needs more setup.
Software side. SDR#, SDRuno, HDSDR, GQRX and CubicSDR all do the same core job of showing a waterfall and demodulating. Each fits a different environment. SDRuno works with SDRplay hardware. HDSDR uses ExtIO drivers and can follow a transceiver over CAT, which suits panadapter use. GQRX is the usual choice on Linux and runs on top of the gr-osmosdr or SoapySDR stack. CubicSDR is cross-platform and goes through SoapySDR. The software matters less than the front end, but features like notch filters, noise blankers and a good bandscope decide how pleasant a receiver is to use.
Noise. A lot of HF noise is local interference rather than the receiver. Switch-mode power supplies, LED lighting, USB hubs and the PC itself can lift the noise floor by many dB. Use a USB extension cable with a ferrite choke, put the dongle away from the computer, and consider a common-mode choke on the coax. Antennas matter too. A short whip indoors will mostly pick up household noise. An outdoor wire, loop or active antenna away from the house usually improves the signal-to-noise ratio more than a better receiver would.
Questions for the thread: at what point is a filter ahead of an 8-bit dongle worth more than a new receiver? Is a panadapter from a transceiver's IF output a better use of money than a standalone SDR? And how do you tell overload from genuine band activity on a waterfall?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11450-getting-usable-hf-from-an-sdr-direct-sampling-vs-upconverter-vs-a-purpose-built-receiver-and-where-the-noise-really-comes-from/Share on other sites