Run, S&P or SO2R? A practical way to decide when a multiplier is worth leaving your run frequency
- Replies 2
- Views 28
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Admin_Terry 1 post
-
Mod_Mike 1 post
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
Most contest advice sounds like "run when you can, S&P when you can't," which doesn't help much in the moment when the rate meter is dropping and the bandmap shows three needed multipliers. This thread is for working out a decision framework you can apply while operating, plus the supporting pieces: N1MM setup, skimmer and spotting, SO2R switching, antennas, and keeping yourself functional for 24 to 48 hours.
Start with the scoring math, because it settles a lot of arguments. In a contest where score is roughly (QSO points) x (multipliers), one new multiplier is worth about as much as Q/M extra QSOs, where Q is your current QSO count and M is your current multiplier count. If you have 1,000 QSOs and 100 multipliers, a new multiplier is worth about 10 average QSOs. Later in the contest, as M saturates and Q keeps growing, each remaining multiplier is worth more QSOs. Early on, when M is small relative to Q, multipliers are very valuable but also easy to find. Late, they are fewer and harder to get. This is a rule of thumb. It assumes every QSO has the same point value and ignores per-band multipliers, which make the same station worth a new multiplier on each band.
The other half is cost. If you are running at a steady 100 QSOs per hour, each minute away from the run frequency costs you roughly 1.5 to 2 QSOs, plus the risk that someone else takes the frequency. A multiplier that takes 30 seconds to find, call and log is cheap. One that needs a pileup fight, repeated callsign repeats or a band change is not. Comparing the expected QSO-equivalent value of the multiplier against the QSOs you give up is more useful than a general feeling about running versus hunting.
Where does SO2R fit? It mostly attacks that cost. While the run radio is calling CQ or exchanging with a caller, the second radio listens for the multiplier. Done well, the dead time in your run (CQ repeats, slow callers, waiting for a reply) becomes searching time. Done badly, it just splits your attention and your copy gets worse on both radios. I would like to hear where people draw the line between "I can handle this" and "I'm making more errors than I'm gaining."
Some specific questions to get the discussion going:
1) What rate drop, measured over a sliding window, makes you leave a run frequency? Do you look at 10-minute rate, 60-minute rate, or the trend?
2) With a skimmer feeding the bandmap, do you trust the spot enough to call without hearing the station first, or do you always confirm the callsign by ear?
3) For band changes, do you follow a fixed schedule based on expected propagation, or change when the rate says the band is dying? Which rules in your contests limit band changes in the category you enter?
4) What is your plan for sleep and breaks, and how do you decide when to take them?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11478-run-sp-or-so2r-a-practical-way-to-decide-when-a-multiplier-is-worth-leaving-your-run-frequency/Share on other sites