Dual-band mobile rig planning: FTM-500D vs ID-5100A vs TM-D710G, plus wiring, noise and etiquette
- Replies 2
- Views 26
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
I'd like to collect practical advice on setting up a 2 meter / 70 centimeter mobile station. The three radios people ask about most are the Yaesu FTM-500D, Icom ID-5100A and Kenwood TM-D710G. They overlap a lot on paper, since all are roughly 50 W-class dual-band mobiles, but they fit different operating styles.
Choosing the radio. The FTM-500D is usually discussed for Yaesu C4FM digital plus analog FM. The ID-5100A is the D-STAR option, with a large touchscreen and GPS-related features. The TM-D710G is known for its built-in APRS/TNC capability and is often mentioned when people want packet, position reporting or cross-band repeat. Features vary by model and firmware, so read the current manual before buying for a specific function. Cross-band repeat in particular is not something to assume on every dual-band mobile.
Cross-band repeat. The idea is that the radio receives on one band and retransmits on the other, for example receiving a handheld on UHF and retransmitting on VHF. It can extend a handheld's reach from a vehicle, but you are operating a repeater-like station. You still need to identify properly, stay within your license privileges, avoid interfering with existing repeaters and follow local rules. Pick frequencies that are clear and legal for that use, and keep a way to stop the station quickly.
Mounting. Pick a spot where the body has airflow, the controls are reachable without taking your eyes off the road, and the unit won't become a projectile in a hard stop. Under-dash brackets, console mounts and seat-adjacent mounts all work if they're bolted to something solid. Keep cables clear of pedals, airbag deployment zones and seat rails. If the radio supports a detachable head, the body can go under a seat or in a trunk, but you'll need the correct separation kit and cable.
Power and fusing. A 50 W FM mobile can draw around a dozen amps on high power transmit. Use the power cable supplied by the manufacturer, or heavier wire if you extend it, and keep any extension short. The fuse should sit close to the battery positive terminal on the positive lead, because it protects the wire, not just the radio. Keep the supplied inline fuses on the radio side too. Route through a proper grommet where the cable passes through the firewall, and never run unprotected wire across sharp edges. Check the manual for the recommended fuse rating and wire gauge.
Noise. Alternator whine, ignition hash and noisy accessories are the usual suspects. Common culprits include cheap USB chargers, dash cams, LED lighting and DC-DC converters. Turn items off one at a time while listening to a quiet frequency, and try ferrite cores on suspect cables. Antenna placement and a good ground connection matter as well, so check SWR before blaming the radio.
Etiquette. Drive first and talk second. Listen before transmitting, keep transmissions short, avoid tying up busy repeaters, and use calling frequencies only to make contact before moving off. Where you live may determine which simplex calling frequencies are common, so check your local band plan.
What mounting locations, antenna types or noise fixes have worked well for people here, and which radio features really matter in daily mobile use?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11479-dual-band-mobile-rig-planning-ftm-500d-vs-id-5100a-vs-tm-d710g-plus-wiring-noise-and-etiquette/Share on other sites