Dual-band mobile radio planning: FTM-500D vs ID-5100A vs TM-D710G, plus wiring, noise and cross-band basics
- Replies 2
- Views 29
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
Picking a 2 meter / 70 centimeter mobile usually comes down to which ecosystem you want, because all three of these radios are 50 W-class dual-banders. The Yaesu FTM-500D is built around C4FM digital with analog FM. The Icom ID-5100A is a D-STAR radio with a touchscreen head and analog FM. The Kenwood TM-D710G is an analog FM radio with built-in APRS (TNC and GPS), and it is often chosen by people who want position reporting and messaging without extra boxes. Check which digital modes are active on the repeaters you actually use before buying. A radio that can't talk to your local network is a lot less useful, however nice its display is.
Whichever radio you choose, the installation matters as much as the model. A few points are worth settling before you drill anything:
Power wiring. A 50 W FM radio can pull roughly 10 to 12 A or more on high-power transmit, so skip the cigarette-lighter socket. Those circuits are shared, thinly wired and add voltage drop. Run the supplied power cable to the battery, with the fuse holder on the positive lead as close to the battery terminal as practical. That fuse protects the cable run, so a fuse only at the radio end leaves the long section unprotected. Use the fuse rating the manufacturer specifies. If you have to extend the cable, use heavier wire than the stock gauge, and make good crimped or soldered joints rather than twisted ones. Use a grommet wherever the cable passes through sheet metal. Some newer vehicles have a battery monitoring sensor on the negative terminal, so check the service information before choosing a ground point.
Mounting. Keep the radio body and control head away from airbag deployment zones and anywhere a loose unit could become a projectile. Leave room around the heatsink and fan. Mount the microphone hanger where you can reach it without looking. If the radio supports a separated head, as the ID-5100A and FTM-500D do, plan the cable route and where the body will live. Don't coil excess coax or cable into a tight bundle beside the radio.
Antenna and feedline. A well-grounded roof-center antenna usually works better than a trunk-lip or magnet mount. At 440 MHz, cheap thin coax loses more than at 146 MHz, so don't skimp on the feedline. Check SWR on both bands, not just one.
Noise. Alternator whine, ignition noise and hash from LED lighting, USB chargers or DC-DC converters can show up as a squelch that won't close, or as whine on your transmitted audio. Keep the power lead away from the vehicle harness, separate it from the coax, and test by switching accessories on and off while listening on a weak signal. Ferrite chokes can help in some cases, but a poor ground or a noisy accessory should be fixed at the source.
For discussion: how do you weigh the digital ecosystem against the features you'd use daily, such as APRS, cross-band repeat and a readable display? And what is your approach to power and ground routing in a newer vehicle?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11492-dual-band-mobile-radio-planning-ftm-500d-vs-id-5100a-vs-tm-d710g-plus-wiring-noise-and-cross-band-basics/Share on other sites