VHF/UHF antenna choices: J-pole, slim jim, 5/8 wave, collinear, yagi, and what matters more than the antenna type
- Replies 2
- Views 30
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
This thread is for comparing common VHF/UHF antenna designs and the installation details that often decide whether they work. The starting question is simple: you want to work local repeaters, simplex, and maybe a satellite pass. Which antenna do you build or buy, and where do you put it?
Quarter-wave whip: about 19 inches on 2 m and about 6.5 inches on 70 cm. It is mechanically simple and has roughly unity gain over a ground plane, so the ground plane is part of the antenna. On a car, the roof is that ground plane. A mag mount on the center of a steel roof behaves very differently from the same whip on a trunk lip or a fiberglass panel.
5/8 wave: the usual step up for mobile and some base antennas. A matching coil at the base cancels the reactance, and the pattern is pushed lower toward the horizon. Ideal gain is about 3 dB over a quarter-wave, but real-world numbers depend heavily on the ground plane and the matching. Dual-band mobile whips often use a 5/8 wave on 2 m and a stacked 5/8 arrangement on 70 cm. The gain ratings are marketing numbers unless the pattern was measured on a proper ground plane.
J-pole and slim jim: both are end-fed half-wave antennas with a quarter-wave matching section. The slim jim is a folded variant of the same idea. Gain is about that of a half-wave dipole, so don't expect more just because it is tall. They are cheap, rugged, and need no radials, but the feedline can still carry common-mode current and distort the pattern. A choke of several turns of coax or a few ferrites at the feedpoint helps, and mounting the antenna away from the mast also helps.
Collinear: stacked half-wave sections phased to narrow the vertical beam. Typical commercial base antennas run from about 6 to 9 dBd. The extra gain comes from squeezing the pattern toward the horizon, so a collinear on a hill or tower is excellent, while one in a valley or near a house may overshoot nearby stations. Mount it high, above surrounding metal, and keep the mast clear of the radiating sections.
Yagi: this is the directional option. Gain depends on boom length, roughly 6 dBd for a few elements and 10 or more for long booms. Use vertical polarization for FM repeaters and simplex, and horizontal for SSB and CW weak-signal work. A rotator is nice, but for a fixed repeater path a fixed yagi aimed at the machine can beat any omni.
Feedline matters as much as the antenna. Loss rises quickly with frequency. As rough numbers, RG-58 is around 4 to 5 dB per 100 ft at 150 MHz and around twice that at 450 MHz. LMR-400-class cable is around 1.5 dB per 100 ft at 150 MHz and 2.7 dB at 450 MHz. Check the datasheet for the exact cable. A 6 dB-gain antenna on a long run of RG-58 can end up worse than a plain dipole on short low-loss coax.
Connectors: the PL-259 (UHF connector) is fine on 2 m at modest power, but it is not constant impedance and is poor on 70 cm and up. An N-type is constant impedance, weatherproof with its gasket, and a better choice for outdoor 440 MHz work. For the car, NMO is the standard for a permanent mount. It needs a 3/4 inch hole and a good ground at the mount, but it is much more reliable than a mag mount for long-term use. Whatever you use, waterproof outdoor connectors with self-amalgamating tape and add a drip loop in the cable.
SWR tells you how well the antenna is matched to the feedline. It does not tell you how well the antenna radiates. A dummy load shows 1:1 and radiates nothing. Measure at the antenna end if you can, because long lossy coax can make a bad antenna look better than it is. Check across the band, not just on one frequency.
Polarization: the mismatch between a vertical and a horizontal antenna on a direct path can be 20 dB or more in theory and typically 10 to 20 dB in practice. Reflections may help or hurt. For satellites, the polarization rotates with Doppler and spacecraft tumbling, so circularly polarized antennas, such as crossed yagis, avoid deep fades. Many people work FM satellites with a handheld Yagi and accept some polarization fading.
What have you found works for your situation, and what do you want to compare: gain versus pattern, cable versus connector, or a build versus buying?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11538-vhfuhf-antenna-choices-j-pole-slim-jim-58-wave-collinear-yagi-and-what-matters-more-than-the-antenna-type/Share on other sites