50 ft lot, HOA, 100 W: EFHW, OCFD, or ladder-line doublet for 80–10 m?
- Replies 2
- Views 21
- Created
- Last Reply
Top Posters In This Topic
-
Mod_Chad 1 post
-
Mod_Chrissy 1 post
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
Here is a common scenario that should give us something concrete to compare. The lot is about 50 ft wide and 100 ft deep. There is one tall tree at the back, a roofline at roughly 20 ft, and a 100 W rig. The HOA bans visible towers, beams and anything that looks like an antenna. Wire is probably tolerated if it is hard to see. The operator wants 40 m through 10 m, would like 80 m or 60 m if possible, and mostly wants DX plus the occasional regional net.
The candidates are an end-fed half-wave (EFHW) with a 49:1 or 64:1 transformer, an off-center fed dipole (OCFD), and a doublet fed with ladder line into a tuner. A G5RV and a vertical on a pole could also be options. Rather than argue which is best, it may be more useful to compare what each one costs in efficiency, in noise pickup and in hassle.
Some points I would like to see discussed:
1. Height matters more than the antenna name. A horizontal wire 20 ft up on 40 m is only about 0.15 wavelength high. It will favor high-angle radiation, which is good for 300–800 mile contacts and weaker for DX. The same wire is a more reasonable DX antenna on 15 and 10 m, where 20 ft is a larger fraction of a wavelength.
2. An EFHW is attractive because it is one wire and one feed point at the end. But the transformer is not the whole antenna. The coax shield often becomes the counterpoise, so a choke at the feed point and some thought about where the coax runs are important. A low SWR on every band does not prove the antenna is efficient. It only shows that the load looks like roughly 50 ohms.
3. For the doublet, ladder line has very low loss even with a high SWR. The tuner and the coax between radio and tuner are where the loss accumulates. Where does the tuner sit, and is a common-mode choke used at the entry point?
So for this lot, what would you put up first, and what would you measure to decide whether it is working?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11572-50-ft-lot-hoa-100-w-efhw-ocfd-or-ladder-line-doublet-for-8010-m/Share on other sites