Small-yard multiband HF wire: EFHW vs OCFD vs G5RV vs doublet, and what really decides performance
- Replies 2
- Views 266
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
Many threads on stealth and small-lot HF antennas turn into a brand argument. It may help to compare the options on the things that actually change the signal: where the current flows, how high the radiating part is, how much loss sits in the feedline and matching device, and how much common-mode current ends up on the coax. Here is a framework to push on, and I'd like corrections.
First, SWR is a matching number, not an efficiency number. A dummy load shows 1:1 and radiates nothing. A vertical over a poor radial field can also show a pleasant SWR because ground loss adds to the feedpoint resistance, which moves it toward 50 ohms. A wire with a 4:1 SWR at the antenna end of a short, low-loss feedline can radiate better than a lossy compromise that reads 1.2:1. SWR only tells you how much power gets into the system. It doesn't tell you how much leaves as RF.
The common wire options sort out roughly like this. An end-fed half-wave (EFHW) presents a very high impedance at the end, often a few thousand ohms, so it needs a transformer with a ratio around 49:1 to 64:1. A half-wave on 40 m also behaves as a half-wave on harmonically related bands such as 20, 15 and 10 m. It does not cover 30 m or 17 m without extra tricks. It is convenient because there's no need to get a feedline to the center of the span, but the coax usually becomes part of the antenna system unless you add a counterpoise or a choke. The transformer core, winding and any compensation capacitor all affect loss and bandwidth, and the loss can be significant at higher power.
An off-center-fed dipole (OCFD, or Windom type) feeds a half-wave wire at roughly the one-third point through a 4:1 or similar current balun. It tends to give usable matches on several harmonically related bands, but the match on a given band depends heavily on exact dimensions, height, and surroundings. The radiation pattern also changes with the band, because on harmonics the current distribution shifts. Common-mode current on the feedline is a real concern here as well, and a choke is cheap insurance.
The G5RV is a roughly 102 ft (31 m) wire with a section of balanced line (about 34 ft) leading to a coax run. It is not a resonant, matched-everywhere antenna. It is a multiband doublet that you tune with an ATU, and the ladder-line section does the work of carrying the mismatch. It is usable but not magic. Its behavior on a given band depends on whether you land at a friendly impedance. Put a choke at the ladder-to-coax transition.
A plain doublet fed with open-wire or window line is the most forgiving approach for loss, because balanced line has far lower loss than coax at high SWR. The price is that you need a balanced-capable tuner, or a tuner plus a good balun, and the line has to be routed into the shack away from metal, which is the hard part in a small yard. Choosing the length so you avoid extremely high or low feedpoint impedances on your favorite bands helps the tuner.
An inverted V is a useful way to fit a dipole on a single mast. A wide apex angle (somewhere near 90 to 120 degrees) keeps the feedpoint near 50 ohms. The legs are slightly shorter than for a flat-top because of end loading and the droop. The tips are high-voltage points, so keep them well above head height. Height matters here: a horizontal wire below about a quarter wavelength mostly sends energy high, which is fine for NVIS-style work on 80 or 40 m but less fine for DX on the higher bands.
Verticals and loops are a different trade. A quarter-wave vertical lives or dies by its ground system. A few elevated, resonant radials can outperform a larger number of short buried radials, and a ground-mounted vertical typically needs a lot of radials before ground loss comes down. A small magnetic loop can be a reasonable stealth option, with a very narrow bandwidth that you must retune, high circulating currents and voltages, and efficiency that depends on the conductor, joints and capacitor. Many people find they also reduce local noise on receive, which can be as valuable as transmit gain if the noise floor is what is holding you back.
For HOA or deed-restricted lots, the stealth part is usually physical. Thin dark wire, trees as supports, a vertical disguised as a flagpole or garden fixture, and a loop that can be put out and taken down can all be practical. Check the actual covenant language. In the US, PRB-1 covers state and local government regulations, but does not by itself override private deed restrictions. Don't let stealth override safety: stay well clear of power lines, plan lightning protection, and keep RF exposure limits in mind for any antenna near living space.
Question for the thread: if you only get one horizontal wire and a tuner, do you spend your effort on getting the wire higher, on getting the feedline loss down, or on common-mode control at the feedpoint? And does a 40 m EFHW make sense as the primary antenna on a lot where a center-fed wire can't be run?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11605-small-yard-multiband-hf-wire-efhw-vs-ocfd-vs-g5rv-vs-doublet-and-what-really-decides-performance/Share on other sites