ⓘ Callsign lookups are in real time via the FCC database.
Vanity callsign availability is refreshed daily at 6:00 AM CST.
The vanity search may be unavailable for a few minutes during this update.
Live DX spots
Live DX Spots — 70cmvia PSKReporter · scroll or pinch to zoom
Band
Mode
Time
Loading map data…
MHzDXSpotterInfo
Recent spots—
Select a band above to load spots
Ready — select a band to fetch live spots
VHF/UHF antenna choices: gain, pattern, feedline and connectors, and where each trade-off bites
Most VHF/UHF antenna arguments come down to the same few trade-offs: gain against beamwidth, convenience against efficiency, and antenna against feedline. This is a starting point for comparing the common options, and I'd like to hear where people think the usual advice falls short.
Quarter-wave, 5/8 wave and what 'gain' means. A quarter-wave whip is about 19 to 20 inches on 2 m and about 6 inches on 70 cm. It is simple, rugged and needs no matching network. It also depends on a ground plane, which on a vehicle is the roof. A 5/8-wave whip is longer and has a matching coil at the base. Its pattern is flatter and pushes more energy toward the horizon, so it often gives a few dB over a quarter-wave in real use. That only holds with a decent ground plane. On a small or off-center ground plane, or on a trunk lip, the pattern can tilt and the gain advantage shrinks. Check whether a spec is in dBi or dBd, because the difference is about 2.15 dB and it makes a big difference to how an advertised number reads.
Collinears and pattern. A collinear stacks phased half-wave sections so that the elevation pattern is squeezed toward the horizon. More gain means a thinner doughnut. That works well on flat ground or a tall mast with a distant target. It is less helpful in hilly terrain, or when you are close to a repeater and below the main lobe. Many gain-antenna complaints are really elevation pattern problems rather than faulty antennas.
J-pole and Slim Jim. Both are end-fed half-wave verticals with a quarter-wave matching section. The Slim Jim is essentially a folded J-pole, and both are popular homebrew projects because they need little ground plane and are cheap to build from ladder line, copper pipe or twin-lead. Don't ignore the feedline, though. With no real ground plane, the coax shield can carry common-mode current and become part of the antenna. That distorts the pattern and shifts the SWR as the cable is moved. A choke or a few ferrite turns near the feedpoint, and a vertical run of coax away from the antenna, often helps more than adjusting the antenna itself.
Yagis and polarization. A yagi gives gain and front-to-back ratio in a defined direction. Gain generally scales with boom length, and bandwidth narrows as you add directors. The polarization convention matters. FM repeater and simplex work is almost always vertical. Weak-signal SSB and CW on 2 m and 70 cm is conventionally horizontal. Cross-polarized links can lose a lot of signal in theory, often 20 dB or more, but reflections and multipath mean real-world loss varies. It is still not something to throw away when you can match it.
Repeater and satellite antennas. For repeater use, a vertical omni or a small yagi aimed at the machine is usually enough. If the repeater is distant and you have terrain obstacles, the yagi's front-to-back ratio can also reject interference from other directions. For satellites, the main problems are changing direction, Doppler shift and polarization fading as the satellite tumbles or the geometry changes. A handheld with a small hand-held yagi can work on strong passes. Fixed setups often use crossed yagis with circular polarization, or separate antennas for uplink and downlink, along with a rotator or manual tracking. A circularly polarized antenna avoids the deep fades you can get with linear polarization, at the cost of a bit of gain.
Mobile mounting. A magnetic mount depends on a steel roof and a clean contact surface. It couples to the roof capacitively, so grit under the magnet and a thin cable routed through a door can both cause trouble. A fixed NMO mount (a 3/4 inch hole and a threaded base) gives a better electrical bond to the vehicle body and a more predictable ground plane. The whip itself must be tuned or trimmed to the intended band. A trunk lip or hood mount works, but the pattern is less symmetrical because of the vehicle's shape.
Coax and connectors. Loss rises quickly with frequency. Thin RG-58 type cable can lose several dB per 100 ft on 2 m and noticeably more on 70 cm. Larger low-loss cable such as LMR-400 or RG-213 types (check the datasheet) lose far less. A 20 ft run is usually fine on small cable, but a 100 ft run to a mast needs the better stuff. For connectors, PL-259 (the UHF connector) is common and adequate on HF and 2 m, but it is not a constant-impedance design and is not well sealed. N-type is constant impedance, handles 70 cm and above better, and has a gasket for weatherproofing. Every adapter adds loss and another place for water to get in, so minimize them.
SWR. A low SWR at the transmitter does not prove the antenna is good. Lossy coax can make a mismatched antenna look better than it is because the reflected power is attenuated on the way back. A dummy load, or a short length of coax, gives a useful sanity check. An antenna analyzer at the antenna end of the feedline shows what the antenna really does. Around 1.5:1 or better is fine for most FM work, but a low SWR can still come with poor pattern or a bad ground.
Where do people think the biggest practical gains are: better feedline, better antenna placement, or a higher-gain design? And do you reach for N-type connectors by default on 70 cm, or is PL-259 good enough for short runs?
Most VHF/UHF antenna arguments come down to the same few trade-offs: gain against beamwidth, convenience against efficiency, and antenna against feedline. This is a starting point for comparing the common options, and I'd like to hear where people think the usual advice falls short.
Quarter-wave, 5/8 wave and what 'gain' means. A quarter-wave whip is about 19 to 20 inches on 2 m and about 6 inches on 70 cm. It is simple, rugged and needs no matching network. It also depends on a ground plane, which on a vehicle is the roof. A 5/8-wave whip is longer and has a matching coil at the base. Its pattern is flatter and pushes more energy toward the horizon, so it often gives a few dB over a quarter-wave in real use. That only holds with a decent ground plane. On a small or off-center ground plane, or on a trunk lip, the pattern can tilt and the gain advantage shrinks. Check whether a spec is in dBi or dBd, because the difference is about 2.15 dB and it makes a big difference to how an advertised number reads.
Collinears and pattern. A collinear stacks phased half-wave sections so that the elevation pattern is squeezed toward the horizon. More gain means a thinner doughnut. That works well on flat ground or a tall mast with a distant target. It is less helpful in hilly terrain, or when you are close to a repeater and below the main lobe. Many gain-antenna complaints are really elevation pattern problems rather than faulty antennas.
J-pole and Slim Jim. Both are end-fed half-wave verticals with a quarter-wave matching section. The Slim Jim is essentially a folded J-pole, and both are popular homebrew projects because they need little ground plane and are cheap to build from ladder line, copper pipe or twin-lead. Don't ignore the feedline, though. With no real ground plane, the coax shield can carry common-mode current and become part of the antenna. That distorts the pattern and shifts the SWR as the cable is moved. A choke or a few ferrite turns near the feedpoint, and a vertical run of coax away from the antenna, often helps more than adjusting the antenna itself.
Yagis and polarization. A yagi gives gain and front-to-back ratio in a defined direction. Gain generally scales with boom length, and bandwidth narrows as you add directors. The polarization convention matters. FM repeater and simplex work is almost always vertical. Weak-signal SSB and CW on 2 m and 70 cm is conventionally horizontal. Cross-polarized links can lose a lot of signal in theory, often 20 dB or more, but reflections and multipath mean real-world loss varies. It is still not something to throw away when you can match it.
Repeater and satellite antennas. For repeater use, a vertical omni or a small yagi aimed at the machine is usually enough. If the repeater is distant and you have terrain obstacles, the yagi's front-to-back ratio can also reject interference from other directions. For satellites, the main problems are changing direction, Doppler shift and polarization fading as the satellite tumbles or the geometry changes. A handheld with a small hand-held yagi can work on strong passes. Fixed setups often use crossed yagis with circular polarization, or separate antennas for uplink and downlink, along with a rotator or manual tracking. A circularly polarized antenna avoids the deep fades you can get with linear polarization, at the cost of a bit of gain.
Mobile mounting. A magnetic mount depends on a steel roof and a clean contact surface. It couples to the roof capacitively, so grit under the magnet and a thin cable routed through a door can both cause trouble. A fixed NMO mount (a 3/4 inch hole and a threaded base) gives a better electrical bond to the vehicle body and a more predictable ground plane. The whip itself must be tuned or trimmed to the intended band. A trunk lip or hood mount works, but the pattern is less symmetrical because of the vehicle's shape.
Coax and connectors. Loss rises quickly with frequency. Thin RG-58 type cable can lose several dB per 100 ft on 2 m and noticeably more on 70 cm. Larger low-loss cable such as LMR-400 or RG-213 types (check the datasheet) lose far less. A 20 ft run is usually fine on small cable, but a 100 ft run to a mast needs the better stuff. For connectors, PL-259 (the UHF connector) is common and adequate on HF and 2 m, but it is not a constant-impedance design and is not well sealed. N-type is constant impedance, handles 70 cm and above better, and has a gasket for weatherproofing. Every adapter adds loss and another place for water to get in, so minimize them.
SWR. A low SWR at the transmitter does not prove the antenna is good. Lossy coax can make a mismatched antenna look better than it is because the reflected power is attenuated on the way back. A dummy load, or a short length of coax, gives a useful sanity check. An antenna analyzer at the antenna end of the feedline shows what the antenna really does. Around 1.5:1 or better is fine for most FM work, but a low SWR can still come with poor pattern or a bad ground.
Where do people think the biggest practical gains are: better feedline, better antenna placement, or a higher-gain design? And do you reach for N-type connectors by default on 70 cm, or is PL-259 good enough for short runs?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11623-vhfuhf-antenna-choices-gain-pattern-feedline-and-connectors-and-where-each-trade-off-bites/Share on other sites