Picking a VHF/UHF antenna: J-pole, slim jim, 5/8 whip, collinear or yagi, and where the dB really go
- Replies 2
- Views 18
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
Antenna choice on 2 m and 70 cm tends to turn into a gain-number contest. The spec sheet says 6 dBi, so it must beat the 3 dBi antenna. In practice, pattern shape, polarization, feedline loss and the installation matter at least as much as the headline figure. This thread is for comparing the common designs and the practical details around them.
Quarter-wave whip. The simplest vertical is a quarter-wave radiator over a ground plane. On 2 m the element is about 19 inches (roughly 48 cm), and on 70 cm about 6.5 inches. It has a low-angle pattern, a feedpoint impedance close to 50 ohms, and little to go wrong. It needs a decent ground plane, which is why a roof-center NMO mount works so well. A mag mount on a small or curved surface gives a lopsided pattern and a less predictable match.
5/8 wave. A 5/8-wave vertical usually needs a matching coil at the base. It concentrates energy a little closer to the horizon than a quarter-wave, so manufacturers typically quote about 3 dB over a quarter-wave. That figure assumes a good ground plane. On a small plane, or a vehicle with a sloping roof, the real-world difference shrinks and the pattern can tilt upward. A 5/8-wave also depends more on the coil and the mount than a quarter-wave does.
J-pole and slim jim. Both are end-fed half-wave designs with a quarter-wave matching section, so they need no radials in principle. In practice the outside of the coax can carry current and distort the pattern and SWR. A choke, such as several turns of coax or a ferrite sleeve at the feedpoint, often helps more than trimming the antenna. A slim jim is essentially a folded variation that gives a somewhat lower takeoff angle. The gain difference between a well-built J-pole and a slim jim is small, and construction accuracy and feedline decoupling matter more than which one you build.
Collinears. Stacked in-phase half-wave sections compress the pattern vertically, trading elevation beamwidth for gain. That is great for a repeater or base station on flat terrain, but a very long collinear can leave nearby or elevated stations in a null. Whip mounted on a hill or tall building often suffers from this, so more gain isn't always better for the coverage area you want.
Yagis. A 3-element yagi gives somewhere around 7 dBi and a 5-element around 10 dBi, with a front-to-back ratio that helps reject interference. Use vertical polarization for FM and repeater work, and horizontal for SSB and CW weak-signal operation. Cross-polarized signals can lose 10 to 20 dB or more, though reflections make the real figure vary a lot.
Feedline and connectors. At VHF/UHF, coax loss climbs quickly with frequency. Small cable such as RG-58 is acceptable for short runs, but at 70 cm over 50 to 100 ft it eats a large share of your power and your receive signal. Larger low-loss cable such as LMR-400 type or RG-213 is a better choice for longer runs. Check the manufacturer's datasheet for the frequency you use. The PL-259/SO-239 (UHF connector) is fine on 2 m and common on HF, but it is not constant-impedance and is a poor choice at 70 cm and above. An N-type is better matched, better sealed and a better fit for outdoor UHF installations. Whatever you use, weatherproof the joint properly, because water in coax can ruin it.
SWR. A low SWR means the antenna system presents a good match to the transmitter. It does not mean the antenna is radiating efficiently. Lossy coax can make SWR read well at the radio end while much of the power is turned into heat. To judge the antenna itself, compare readings at the feedpoint and at the radio, or use an antenna analyzer.
What are people running, and what compromises have they found worth making? I'm especially interested in mobile mounting choices (NMO vs mag mount), repeater-site antenna spacing, and what works for satellites with a handheld versus a dedicated crossed-yagi setup.
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11675-picking-a-vhfuhf-antenna-j-pole-slim-jim-58-whip-collinear-or-yagi-and-where-the-db-really-go/Share on other sites