Reading band conditions: how much do SFI, A and K tell you compared with WSPR, beacons and spots?
- Replies 2
- Views 14
- Created
- Last Reply
A better way to browse. Learn more.
A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.
Solar indices are easy to quote and easy to over-read. Most of us check a banner showing SFI, A index and K index, and then decide whether to bother calling CQ on 15 or 10 metres. I'd like to compare approaches here, because the numbers answer some questions and not others.
What the indices tell you. SFI is the 10.7 cm solar radio flux. It works as a proxy for the solar ultraviolet output that ionises the F region. Higher flux generally means higher F2 critical frequencies, so a higher MUF on long paths. It does not guarantee an opening. Season, local time at both ends, path geometry and geomagnetic conditions all matter. A single SFI value also hides the difference between a good day at solar maximum and a marginal one near minimum.
The A index is a daily summary of geomagnetic disturbance. The K index is a quasi-logarithmic 3-hour measure from 0 to 9. A quiet field with K at 0 to 2 is usually kind to high-latitude and transpolar paths. When K climbs, the F layer can become depressed or disturbed and polar paths tend to degrade first. Auroral flutter on the signals is a common symptom. A high A index with a quiet current K is a different situation from a K spike happening right now, so the timing matters.
The D layer. The D layer is the daytime absorber. It matters most on 160, 80 and 40 metres, because absorption falls off steeply as frequency rises. It fades after sunset, which is why the low bands open up at night. A solar flare can cause a sudden ionospheric disturbance. When a strong flare hits, HF on the sunlit side can go very weak for a while even though the SFI looks healthy. GOES X-ray flux data shows this directly, and much better than the daily flux number does.
Where the F layer and MUF fit. The question I care about is the MUF for my specific path at this hour. A band can be fine at one end of a path and closed at the other. A rough habit is to prefer frequencies at or somewhat below the MUF, since going too high means the signal passes through the layer, and too low means more absorption. On DX paths, the gray line adds a useful opportunity. Both ends have little D-layer absorption near the terminator, so low-band paths that are marginal at other times can work for a short window.
The other mechanisms. Sporadic E is unpredictable and not tied to the sunspot cycle in the same way. In the northern hemisphere its main season is around early summer, with a smaller winter peak. It can bring 10 m, 6 m and sometimes 2 m paths of well over a thousand kilometres, often with multi-hop extensions. Tropospheric ducting is a separate VHF and UHF effect. It is associated with temperature inversions, stable high pressure and sometimes evaporation ducts over water. NVIS is closer to a design problem than a prediction problem. Low-angle antennas are the wrong tool. You want a low horizontal dipole or similar, and a frequency below the F2 critical frequency, so that signals return from steep angles to cover a regional area.
Prediction versus measurement. VOACAP gives monthly median predictions from a smoothed sunspot number, your power and antennas, and a required SNR and reliability. It is good for planning which band to try at which hour. It will not tell you whether today's conditions are above or below the median. For that, I lean on measurement. WSPR lets you transmit at low power and see on the map who heard you. The NCDXF/IARU beacons on 14.100, 18.110, 21.150, 24.930 and 28.200 MHz cycle through their schedule and let you check several directions in minutes. PSKReporter and the Reverse Beacon Network show who is actually being heard, though they depend on who is active and where the listening stations are.
My questions for the thread: what is your order of operations? Do you start with the indices, a VOACAP plot, or a quick look at spots? And what are the limits of spot data when your antenna is far from average?
Link to comment
https://www.hamradiobase.com/forums/topic/11783-reading-band-conditions-how-much-do-sfi-a-and-k-tell-you-compared-with-wspr-beacons-and-spots/Share on other sites