A common vertical-antenna surprise: you add radials, expecting everything to improve, and the SWR meter gets worse. Or you start with a vertical that shows a lovely 1.2:1 and discover it radiates poorly. Both outcomes come from the same fact. SWR measures impedance match, not efficiency. Once you separate those two ideas, radial experiments make a lot more sense.
What the feedpoint resistance is made of
At resonance, the resistance you see at the base of a vertical is the sum of several parts:
- Radiation resistance, the part that actually makes signal. For a quarter-wave vertical over a good ground this is roughly 35–37 Ω.
- Ground loss resistance, which comes from current flowing through lossy soil under and around the antenna.
- Conductor and coil losses, usually small on a full-size wire or tube vertical but significant on loaded or shortened designs.
Power in the loss resistances turns into heat. If ground loss adds 15 Ω to a 36 Ω radiation resistance, the feedpoint reads about 51 Ω. The SWR looks perfect, but nearly 30% of your power is going into the dirt. Add radials and the ground loss drops, the feedpoint resistance falls toward 36 Ω, and the SWR on 50 Ω coax creeps up to about 1.4:1. The antenna got better and the meter got worse.
Use R and X, not just SWR
A NanoVNA is ideal here because it can display resistance and reactance, not only SWR. Before changing anything, record:
- The frequency where reactance crosses zero (resonance).
- The resistance at that frequency.
- The SWR sweep across the whole band, saved or screenshotted.
After each change, repeat the same sweep with the same cable and calibration. Calibrate at the end of the cable or at the antenna feedpoint when you can. A long coax run, if not accounted for, will smear the readings. If you must measure through the coax, use a length of known electrical behavior, such as a half-wavelength multiple, or accept that the numbers are approximate and compare only like with like.
A sensible way to run a radial experiment
Change one variable at a time. A simple progression for a ground-mounted vertical might look like this:
- Measure with a small number of radials, say four.
- Double the count, re-measure, and note the change in resistance and resonant frequency.
- Keep doubling as far as is practical, watching how much each step changes the numbers.
You will typically see big changes at first and smaller ones later. Published field measurements by antenna researchers have shown this pattern of diminishing returns for buried and ground-laid radials: going from a handful to a few dozen helps a lot, while going far beyond that gives smaller gains. Your own soil will set where your curve flattens, which is exactly why measuring beats guessing.
Radial length matters less than count for ground-laid systems. Many short radials usually beat a few long ones, because the goal is to intercept the return currents near the base where they are strongest. Don't expect the numbers to be identical to a textbook, since the soil under your lawn isn't a textbook.
Elevated radials behave differently
If the radials are raised off the ground, a few resonant ones can do the job, because they form a reasonably self-contained counterpoise and couple less to the soil. Two to four tuned quarter-wave radials is a common starting point. Drooping them downward at an angle also raises the feedpoint resistance toward 50 Ω, which can give a natural match to coax without extra hardware. Resonant elevated radials do need trimming, and the VNA will tell you when they are close: look for the feedpoint reactance and the resonant frequency to settle as you adjust.
Keep the radial ends away from people and pets. They can carry high voltage at the tips, especially at higher power levels.
Check the choke too
A vertical with an inadequate ground system tends to push common-mode current onto the feed line, because the coax shield becomes part of the antenna system. If your readings change when you move or touch the coax, or if the noise floor is unusually high, add a common-mode choke near the feedpoint and compare again. It is a separate fix from the radials, but the two interact, so test them separately and note each result.
Measuring the real-world benefit
Impedance readings tell you what the antenna is doing electrically, but not directly how well it radiates. A few ways to check, each with caveats:
- Receive comparison. Switch between the new and old setup on the same band and compare signal-to-noise ratio on a steady signal such as a beacon or broadcast station. This is a fair test only if you switch quickly, since propagation drifts.
- Remote reports. Spotting networks such as WSPR and the Reverse Beacon Network let you compare how you are heard. Alternate configurations in short, repeated intervals, because a single before-and-after pair can be skewed by band conditions.
- Local field strength. A simple field-strength probe at a fixed spot some distance away can show relative changes, as long as you keep the probe position identical and the power constant.
None of these is laboratory grade, but a trend that holds across several repeated trials is meaningful.
Keep a log
Write down the date, band, radial count and layout, feed line, choke, and VNA readings for each stage. Weather and soil moisture can shift ground-loss numbers noticeably, so repeating a measurement on a different day is a useful sanity check. If dry and wet soil give different feedpoint resistances, that tells you something about how much of your antenna's performance depends on the ground.
Takeaways
- SWR is a match indicator, not an efficiency indicator.
- A falling feedpoint resistance after adding radials usually means less ground loss, even if SWR rises a little.
- Add radials in steps and measure each step; expect diminishing returns.
- Test choke and radial changes separately so you know what each one did.
- Confirm with on-air or receive comparisons, repeated enough times to filter out propagation changes.
A vertical that reads a bit higher in SWR but sends more of your power into the air is a better antenna than one that looks perfect on the meter and warms the lawn. Let the R and X numbers guide you, and treat a lower SWR as a bonus rather than the goal.
-
- 9 views
- 0 comments